Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors
by dietrichepp on Saturday November 28, 2015 @01:21AM
(#10640243)
I understand your worries about mob justice, but I think they are misplaced.
Ordinarily, mens rea is necessary for any kind of criminal liability. Mens rea comes in a bunch of different flavors, and different crimes are committed depending on the flavor. For example, if you kill someone, it is murder if you purposefully killed them, but could be manslaughter if you were merely reckless.
So, you can prosecute a prosecutor who knowingly withholds forensic evidence, and the prosecutor next door who is reckless and throws evidence out will just lose his job. You even have to establish beyond a reasonable doubt that the prosecutor was knowingly withholding forensic evidence. That is how criminal law ordinarily works.
But I do believe solving this would be an important victory for rule of law, giving wrongfully-prosecuted citizens a viable legal path for redress of grievance. Just off the top of my head, I would say that the worst penalty anybody should have for not doing their job properly is to lose that job, and that the system should be set up to properly train them and to absorb the costs of someone screwing up. Any other kind of work environment is abusive. So limiting liability to civil damages paid out by the government in malicious prosecution cases makes sense to me. Much as I want to clap these assholes in irons and make them serve alongside the people they wrongfully convicted, I don't think that's objectively the right move here.