News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by tcj_phx on Friday November 27, 2015 @08:37PM (#10639657)
I was recently arrested for the first time.

My girlfriend had ended up in the behavioral health wing of the hospital emergency room when she decided to quit methadone cold-turkey, without any medical support for the withdrawal. When they wouldn't let her go after she'd come to her senses, I went to the courts and obtained an order that the hospital release her. The hospital staff, acting on incorrect legal advice from their staff attorney (who decided to not attend my court hearing), didn't want to hear about the court's order.

I went to the area of my girlfriend's room. The windows are one-way mirrors, but she saw me and started tapping gleefully. I showed her the court order, and did a little dance while waiting for the police to arrive.

Then the entire security staff showed up to deal with me. The "old man" security guard freaked out when I took out my camera-phone to take selfies to document the situation, and tried to remove my phone from my hands. I backed away while trying to switch my phone to video mode...

The wanna-be-cop escalated the fight. Three or four of them wrestled me to the ground while trying to remove my phone from my hands. Eventually I was over-powered and handcuffed. The security guards finally managed to pry my phone from my handcuffed hands. It dropped to the concrete a few feet away, and I got a good view of a boot stomping down to break the screen.

The police officer I'd called for showed up shortly thereafter, but it was six hospital security guards vs. me. The police officer and his superior called the superior court to verify that the case number on my court order was genuine, but it didn't matter. My arresting officer was almost apologetic for taking their side. At the booking area, the officer took pictures of my scuffs and bruises, and of my phone's broken screen (apparently this is much more than is done for most who are arrested).

As I was taking my concrete nap, I thought to contact a facebook-friend who went to Harvard Law School & ask him if he had anyone to recommend. I was released on my own recognizance after spending the night in the city jail's holding cell. The next day I dropped $1000 on a retainer, which isn't much lawyer-time at all, but it's all I had. He's been very helpful in helping me navigate the legal system.

When I got the police report a month later, I learned that the security guard told the police that I'd dropped my phone and hit him 3 times when he went to retrieve it. My video is quite brief, but strongly suggests that the security guard was not at all truthful with his statements that got me arrested for assault.

The next court date was a pretrial conference, about 3 weeks later. The city prosecutor offered a "disorderly conduct" plea. I signed up for a public defender, who I met after another month. He used to work for that hospital, a long time ago. He said something that was informative, but which greatly irritated me, so I borrowed a few thousand dollars from family for a private attorney.

This is going to take a while.

It is very hard to protect people from the system. If you ever find yourself getting caught up in something where the police might get involved, remember that video is much more valuable than photos... (There was a recent story about someone who was vindicated by photos/videos which were automatically-uploaded from his phone which went missing after an police altercation).

Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by e40 on Friday November 27, 2015 @08:54PM (#10639695)
What you describe (people in positions of power telling lies to get out from under bad behavior) seems so common these days that it really makes me wonder how we got here. How did truth and justice get demoted so far, and how did we create so many people that can clearly sleep at night after these lies?
Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by gnaritas on Friday November 27, 2015 @09:42PM (#10639787)
> seems so common these days that it really makes me wonder how we got here. How did truth and justice get demoted so far, and how did we create so many people that can clearly sleep at night after these lies?

I think the answer is simply that we've always been here and you're just coming to realize the truth and justice propaganda was bullshit all along.

Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by mr_luc on Friday November 27, 2015 @10:07PM (#10639843)
"We've always been here" is true, in that even in countries that enjoy relatively good justice systems have people who fall through the cracks ... and people with power at every level for whom the theoretical good functioning of the justice system is a terrible nuisance.

"We've always been here" is also false in the sense that, of course, things used to be quite a lot worse everywhere, and that the current rule of law in many countries today would be considered utopian by the people who died in worse periods of human history.

Which point of view is more beneficial for society to embrace?

Hands down, I think it's "truth and justice propaganda was BS." It's in society's best interests to watch everyone with power like a hawk.

Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by gnaritas on Saturday November 28, 2015 @12:06AM (#10640091)
> and that the current rule of law in many countries today would be considered Utopian by the people who died in worse periods of human history.

Which while absolutely true, makes it no less corrupt. Better doesn't mean good. Less corrupt than before is still corrupt.

> It's in society's best interests to watch everyone with power like a hawk.

More importantly, that that power be continually forced to justify itself else the power be removed.

Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by tcj_phx on Friday November 27, 2015 @09:04PM (#10639719)
> How did truth and justice get demoted so far, and how did we create so many people that can clearly sleep at night after these lies?

Everyone at the hospital thought their behavior was justified. My brother said something about the foolishness of getting in an altercation with $10/hour security guards.

Eventually their insurance company is probably going to intervene to help rewrite their policies & procedures.

Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by protomyth on Friday November 27, 2015 @10:08PM (#10639848)
> Eventually their insurance company is probably going to intervene to help rewrite their policies & procedures.

Sadly, that's the entity that actually has the power to force these institutions to stop doing dumb things.

Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by siberianbear on Saturday November 28, 2015 @03:31AM (#10640491)
Thank you for posting that story.

It reminds me of this story written by a startup founder who got a bit beat up and jailed by idiot cops for no good reason: https://human.parts/good-samaritan-backfire-9f53ef6a1c10#.jv...

Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by tcj_phx on Saturday November 28, 2015 @12:18PM (#10641637)
Thanks for commenting, and for posting the link. This quote is excellent:

"Once within the system, resistance is futile. I couldn’t help but recall a wise criminal lawyer’s (and friend’s) remarks: “Extricate yourself from the system, don’t try to vindicate yourself within it.”"

Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by ridgeguy on Friday November 27, 2015 @09:40PM (#10639784)
Are there security cameras that might have covered any of what happened to you? Suggest you immediately find out and if there are, have your counsel subpoena the records. Speed is important to make sure the records aren't written over "for economic reasons".
Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by tcj_phx on Friday November 27, 2015 @10:08PM (#10639850)
The police officer said he & his superior looked for cameras, but that none were pointed in the right direction. My counsel said that large facilities frequently don't keep the videos for more than a week, but sent a "preservation letter" anyways:

"The goal of the preservation letter is, of course, to remind opponents to preserve evidence, to be sure the evidence doesn’t disappear." - http://www.craigball.com/perfect%20preservation%20letter.pdf

Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by protomyth on Friday November 27, 2015 @10:28PM (#10639896)
I hope you get one hell of a check. I do wonder if there is an actual device people can carry that can document your life during these incidents that automatically uploads in case it is "lost" or "broken" in the incident. It probably also needs to not look like a camera.
Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by tcj_phx on Saturday November 28, 2015 @02:08AM (#10640320)
I would have rather gone on the trip we had planned.
Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by protomyth on Saturday November 28, 2015 @08:04AM (#10640953)
Most people would have. Sadly, some idiots took that option away, and the best you can get in civil court is a check. I hope fools will cause you and yours no pain in the future.
Re:How to Prosecute Abusive Prosecutors by justinclift on Sunday November 29, 2015 @07:35PM (#10646902)
One of the few(?) compelling arguments for cloud storage with no cave-in ability for law enforcement. :/