What if it were for you personally? A year of your life? Would you calmly agree that it's not a well settled constitutional right and happily wait it out?
There are a lot of shitty state governments trying to read stuff like Roe v. Wade out of existence. Singling out one particular judge who happened to make stupid comments in an interview won't change those policies. That has to happen at the state level.
The issues are far worse than this one judge of course, they are widespread as the article states but it's very nice to have an example of the thought process and behavior of some of these people for those of who haven't encountered the criminal justice system before or aren't trained in law.
Too bad, but starting with the destruction of the careers of people who should have exercised discretion may be what has to happen when the system is unresponsive. Too bad about whether it should be a matter for the people of that state. They don't get to run a legal swamp in isolation.
Arguably they should get to do that, if that's what the people want. After all, framers never intended for the federal government to impose uniform standards on state justice systems.
Technically correct, but you have to ignore the XIIIth and XIVth to make that relevant to today.
But, yeah, Reconstruction and subsequent events shaped those Amendments.
> As for having an attorney, yes, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 1963 that defendants have a right to one but the debate about just when the right-to-counsel “attaches” continues to evolve. While the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in a 2008 case, Rothgery v Gillespie, that the accused are entitled to an attorney at every “critical stage” of the process, it did not clearly define what constituted a “critical stage.”
> Most places have interpreted this to mean at the initial bail hearing. But not Mississippi.
It doesn't seem to be entirely a case of a renegade judge ignoring a well-settled Constitutional right.