News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Real Programming in Functional Languages (1982) [pdf] by platz on Thursday November 26, 2015 @04:48PM (#10634890)
Some excepts from the Conclusions section are fairly amusing:

"One way to compromise between functional and imperative programming is recognize that every language has a functional subset, usually associated with the set of expressions in the language. However, it is rarely useful to take advantage of the functional subset via clever evaluation or compilation strategies because expressions in that subset usually represent very small intervals of computation or leave the functional subset via calls on functions with side effects"

"Functional languages as a minority doctrine in the field of programming languages bear a certain resemblance to socialism in its relation to conventional, capitalist economic doctrine. Their proponents are often brilliant intellectuals perceived to be radical and rather unrealistic by the mainstream, but little-by-little changes are made in the conventional languages and economies to incorporate features of the radical proposals. Of course this never satisfies the radicals, but it represents progress of a sort."

"A little appreciated role of functional programming, goto-less programming, and other stylish forms of programming is an indicator of a programmer's morale. When one comes across a program with a rat's nest of gotos, or large amounts of pointer arithmetic one says to himself, "This programmer was barely able to solve the problem he was working on. If he had the intellectual problem well under control, then he should have devoted some of his brainpower to making it look pretty according to generally accepted standards, e.g. eliminating gotos."

Re:Real Programming in Functional Languages (1982) [pdf] by jpgauthier on Thursday November 26, 2015 @05:13PM (#10634976)
The second quote is so true. I never thought of it that way!
Re:Real Programming in Functional Languages (1982) [pdf] by hcarvalhoalves on Thursday November 26, 2015 @07:04PM (#10635266)
This quote is so misleading.

Since when functional programming is "radical"? It's the essence of computing.

What we're seeing are other languages going back to the basics, after a detour in the "imperative is easy to learn" and "OO is reusable" lands.

Re:Real Programming in Functional Languages (1982) [pdf] by vegabook on Thursday November 26, 2015 @07:17PM (#10635290)
machine code looks pretty much like the "essence of computing" to me, and that's about as far as you can get from functional programming. I think I would agree with you more if you meant the essence of computer "science". If I remember correctly there is, anyway, a theorem by Church and Turing that proves imperative and functional programming to be capability-equivalent. The argument is more about the superiority of functional programming in its benefits to software engineering and algorithm discovery by forcing rigour onto our mistake-prone brains.
Re:Real Programming in Functional Languages (1982) [pdf] by rtpg on Thursday November 26, 2015 @07:46PM (#10635356)
>Since when functional programming is "radical"? It's the essence of computing.

It isn't representative of how processors work, unlike imperative programming. Even if the theory is there, the machine itself is imperative (most of the time), so there's a level of abstraction needed.

Though the theory could have started like that, the mechanisms are totally separated from the physical reality. In a field dominated by engineers (especially in a time where cycle counts mattered much more), that's what's going to happen.

Re:Real Programming in Functional Languages (1982) [pdf] by tel on Thursday November 26, 2015 @11:37PM (#10635874)
Well, increasingly that's untrue as machine operation begins to become more data flow oriented. Even before it hits the machine optimizations are often better performed on analyses which are more "functional" in nature. SSA is not so far from a functional language.
Re:Real Programming in Functional Languages (1982) [pdf] by jandrese on Thursday November 26, 2015 @10:30PM (#10635710)
There were honest to god LISP machines built back in the day. They never really caught on however. They were mostly oriented at the educational market, and didn't ship with such niceties like an OS or even a bootloader sometimes.
Re:Real Programming in Functional Languages (1982) [pdf] by jpt4 on Thursday November 26, 2015 @11:07PM (#10635802)
>> the mechanisms are totally separated from the physical reality.

> There were honest to god LISP machines

As LISP-flavored stack machines, yes [0]. Alas that Linear Lisp [1] never received a hardware implementation [2].

To those exploring high level language architectures, forget not also the noble SCHEME-79 chip [3]: a Von Neumannian register machine, but one which executes a SCHEME interpreter microcoded in LISP.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisp_machine#Technical_overvie...

[1] http://home.pipeline.com/~hbaker1/LinearLisp.html

[2] http://home.pipeline.com/~hbaker1/ForthStack.html

[3] http://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/6334