News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You've been Yelped by scott_s on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:07PM (#1063021)
Max (the article's author), I saw that you're posting in the thread. Reading the account on the first page, the bookstore owner sounds troubled. She won't clean her store, and when someone leaves (what I think is) a review with valid criticism, she responds with vitriol. Considering her prior behavior and the fact that the authorities sided with him, I'm inclined to believe Clare's account of the altercation. I don't always cede to the authorities. But considering that the stereotypes were stacked against Clare - male, younger - I bet the cops who interviewed the two decided that Goodman was unhinged.

Others here have the same impression. So, two questions. Why did you decide to lead the story with her? And are your conclusions regarding her behavior similar to ours?

Re:You've been Yelped by mchafkin on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:21PM (#1063052)
Thanks Scott. I led with her because I think the incident, while extreme, is a vivid illustration of the way that Yelp (and not just Yelp, but all online review sites) is making business owners feel. This owner is not the first or the last to take criticism personally and respond without thinking.

As to your second question, I don't think anyone thinks that the the owner's actions were reasonable. (As I say later I the story, she feels terrible about what happened.) Sean C.'s review was negative, but not overwhelmingly so. And whatever someone says on a review site, I think that everyone has a right to privacy.

Re:You've been Yelped by scott_s on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:31PM (#1063081)
I don't see the anecdote as an example of how Yelp is making business owners feel. I see it as an example of how one sadly troubled woman got into trouble - the mechanism through which that happened seems incidental to me.

By the end of the first page, I'm thinking "This woman sounds crazy," not "Yelp can cause trouble." I don't think she's a good example for the problems Yelp can cause.

I'll read the rest of the article later. But the problem with leading with such an anecdote is that after thinking "This woman sounds crazy," my next thought was "Does this reporter not see that? If not not, is it worth reading the rest?"

Re:You've been Yelped by rubberbunny on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @04:48PM (#1063328)
Doesn't she know she can just become a "Yelp! Sponsor" and have the offending reviews removed?

My whole Yelp account was banned for calling out a local restaurant owner for being so psycho that he made my date cry. It was a mighty coincidence that my account ban and deleted reviews coincided with his shit-hole restaurant deciding to sponsor Yelp.

But I'm sure Yelp has excuses. Maybe I didn't log in frequently enough, or they thought because my experience was so out-there that it must be fake. Either way, I'll never trust or use Yelp again. It's pay for play all the way.

Re:You've been Yelped by Tangurena on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @10:25AM (#1064902)
That sponsorship costs $300/month. That's a lot of money for many small businesses and can easily push a business that's barely scraping by in this economy into the red.

And I don't know about you, but I get angry when I think of people trying to extort $3600/year from me. It is my business - not theirs. Yet somehow I'm the one getting my wallet picked.

Re:You've been Yelped by rubberbunny on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @01:48PM (#1065416)
My bad, cynicism is not easy to convey via text.

To be clear, businesses are not supposed to be able to remove any review from the site. Yelp makes a big deal about claiming that they don't let businesses, even Yelp Sponsors, remove negative reviews. That being said, I know first-hand that they do remove negative reviews, so... fuck Yelp, I guess.

I'm angry too that Yelp pits businesses against customers for profit while claiming to be an unbiased source. Just the fact that it's even possible for a business to "sponsor" an "unbiased" review site should set off a lot of red flags.

Just ran a search on "yelp unbiased" and this popped up: http://ask.metafilter.com/142694/Yelp-sucks-I-need-unbiased-...