Re:Ask HN: How viable is it for a programmer to switch to a ...
by mbrubeck on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @09:08AM
(#1064751)
Nice! Though as a vim user I would rather have a layout that messed with zxcv and instead left hjkl alone... (Colemak is especially bad, with J below K.)
Re:Ask HN: How viable is it for a programmer to switch to a ...
by zck on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @09:58AM
(#1064855)
Ouch, that would be a pain to use. All four of them are on the same finger, even! The problem with leaving hjkl where they are is that it wastes a huge amount of prime real estate. In colemak -- as you've seen -- those keys are used for hnei, all commonly typed letters. jkl are much less common.
I'd recommend it. There are a few modifications I'd make, but overall it's quite nice. They've written programs to check finger travel distance, and it beats QWERTY and Dvorak. A reason to choose it over Dvorak is that it keeps WAZXCVB in the same place, so those common Ctrl-keys are just as easy to press.
There's several versions for Windows, including one that can be run off a flash drive, and work without installation (http://colemak.com/Windows), and Colemak is also built in to X on Linux.
Although depending what you're doing, switching to an alternate keyboard layout can be a problem. For example, if I were a sysadmin, going around to different computers and fixing them, it would be infeasible to switch, unless I put the time in to being able to context-switch my brain quickly, so I could touch-type both.