A small room that increases by a few degrees is storing only slightly more energy. Humans won't really notice it.
A global biosphere is a much larger volume, so a few degrees stores much more energy, compared to the human scale. And that energy is what powers our weather.
Can you think of a weather system you would enjoy with more energy powering it? Stronger storms, stronger winds, greater temperature fluctuations, greater precipitation fluctuations, greater groundwater fluctuations, etc.
Ultimately "the planet" will be just fine under those circumstances, but human society might suffer.
Purposefully cooling us outside that range would also be bad, albeit in different ways.
The rate of change matters too, because people do migrate and refresh their infrastructure. If the rate of change is equal to, or less than, our migration and infrastructure rates, then we can adapt without much additional cost or social strife. Right now, it's predicted to be quite a bit faster. Edit: because of our own activities that are causing warming.
Don't leave us hanging here!