News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How viable is it for a programmer to switch to a ... by mrduncan on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @08:36AM (#1062054)
Not to be snarky but I'm curious what you're doing that you need extremely fast typing for? I rarely find that typing is my bottleneck, it's usually my brain.

That said, why not give it a shot for a day or two? At worst, you'll realize it is going to take forever to regain speed - at best, you're well on your way to using the new layout.

Re:Ask HN: How viable is it for a programmer to switch to a ... by mbrubeck on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @10:08AM (#1062255)
I type about 3x faster* than some of my co-workers, and I can tell when I'm working with them that it does make a difference.

They don't even try do to exploratory programming. In cases where I would just write some throwaway code for an experiment, or turn to a REPL session to answer a question in a few seconds, they start leafing through documentation or Googling for someone else who knows the answer. I write and re-write code while I'm thinking; once they start writing they are unwilling to change their minds mid-stream. Even in normal "batch" programming, it means that instead of 5 minutes of thought followed by 1 minute of typing, they have 5 minutes of thought followed by 3 minutes of typing - so they take longer to resume their stream of thought, and spend slightly less time thinking overall.

*I type about 60wpm which is not especially fast, it's just that I work with some people who are not touch-typists.

Re:Ask HN: How viable is it for a programmer to switch to a ... by jrgnsd on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @08:51AM (#1062085)
It sometimes happen, not often, that my brain needs spurts of speed from my hands, and it's then that I notice that particularly my left hand holds me back. I've taken DVORAK under consideration as it's partly designed to detangle the left hand.

I'm not sure that a valid comparison / assessment can be made after a day or two's use.

Re:Ask HN: How viable is it for a programmer to switch to a ... by mrduncan on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @08:53AM (#1062089)
Fair enough, I should have first stated that I've never tried DVORAK (so take my advice with a block of salt). What about giving it a week then? I suppose my point was that you won't know how hard it is until you give it a shot for a little while. People all learn differently, the only way to know is to just give it a shot.
Re:Ask HN: How viable is it for a programmer to switch to a ... by DanielStraight on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @08:53AM (#1062088)
Obligatory Yegge link on typing: http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2008/09/programmings-dirties...

Typing is definitely the bottleneck for me in some situations, especially when I'm prototyping something, and I can hit 100 wpm without too much difficulty.

As for giving it a several day test drive, I don't think that's going to help at all. The point is that once you know dvorak it is faster than qwerty. It would probably take a least of month of dvorak to be able to make a reasonable evaluation.