News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by dogma1138 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:30AM (#10619902)
Open source drivers are meaningless for gaming, the compiler and driver specific optimizations are not open sourced for AMD neither in the old nor the new driver, and do not seem to ever be. While it's true that AMD has "better" open source drivers I would not go as to say by far, because they are usable and that's about it, you can't use them for gaming no more than you can use the OSS Geforce ones, and on the closed source part NVIDIA driver quality trumps AMD, I wish we were back in the old ATI days with my Hercules Radeon 9800 pro but we aren't. AMD at this point constantly lags behind NVIDIA on everything from performance, to feature support, memory utilization and power consumption.

On the GPGPU front NVIDIA is only "better" at FP when you are talking about HP, FullP is just horrid on everything but it's Tesla and 1st Gen Titan cards. And since you don't need to use FP as much because OpenCL and DX-Compute push towards using advanced INT32 operations (mu, mua, sad) it doesn't fair well, NVIDIA dominated when all of the real world applications used FP in their implementations even when you only had to deal with ints (e.g. SHA256) now when you can do INT32 operations it's dragging it's ass behind GCN for most things that people here would care about (Bitcoin, bruteforcing passwords) even if you are buying Tesla's.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by onli on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:50AM (#10619949)
> While it's true that AMD has "better" open source drivers I would not go as to say by far, because they are usable and that's about it, you can't use them for gaming no more than you can use the OSS Geforce ones

That is wrong. Since a few versions (since Gallium3D arrived, if I got that right) at least you absolutely can use them to game. I played Witcher 2 on them last week. Also many easier games work fine and stable (Kebal, Mark of the Ninja, Mount & Blade… not hard stuff, but still needing working drivers with 3D performance).

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by dogma1138 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:08AM (#10619992)
Being capable of running a game and being viable for gaming are 2 different things, i can run Witcher 2 on a MBP13 with Intel Iris Pro on medium settings at an acceptable frame rate. Neither OSS drivers are going to be viable for a gaming machine e.g. SteamOS Box when It's actually intended to be a gaming machine rather than a machine that occasionally can run games older than X amount of years.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by tankenmate on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:34AM (#10620063)
You need to check the Phoronix Test Suite numbers, for a number of games on all but the latest AMD hardware the OSS drivers are actually faster than the Catalyst ones. One area where the OSS stack is functionally less than Catalyst is OGL 4.3+. I too use the OSS Radeon drivers and find that they are within a few percentage points of Catalyst numbers and occasionally double digit faster.

OSS drivers for the latest AMD hardware (<1 year old) is hit and miss.

EDIT: clarification

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by dogma1138 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @07:32AM (#10620334)
I can check what version I had in SteamOS but 20-30% performance difference in modern games between OSS and closed source AMD drivers as far as 2-3 weeks ago goes on modern AAA titles with Linux support.

I could care less about <1 year old games or synthetic benchmarks tbh.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by tankenmate on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @07:52AM (#10620391)
The versions of the drivers in SteamOS are well behind up to date stable, let alone testing. You can easily pull in one of the many PPAs that track the latest stable and/or testing kernel/MESA/DRM/DRI stacks (such as xorg-edgers, obiaf or others).

If you are not happy with what is provided by stock SteamOS then your issue is with Valve's distribution not the current state of the drivers.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by Shorel on Thursday November 26, 2015 @12:32PM (#10633891)
How much of that difference is because of the driver and how much because of a bad port from the game developer?

Remember all the console to PC ports with really bad performance. Now add the lack of a financial incentive for Linux games.

To put this in perspective, there are more Windows XP users than Linux users in Steam stats.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by madez on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @06:19AM (#10620171)
I have a HD 7950 and I can game very well a lot of games.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by nl on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @06:26AM (#10620188)
it's dragging it's ass behind GCN for most things that people here would care about (Bitcoin, bruteforcing passwords) even if you are buying Tesla's.

For Neural Nets NVIDIA is the only game in town.

The non-open source drivers (and CUDA libraries) are a huge deal though - as anyone who has tried to get <insert DeepLearning of your choice here> working.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by zanny on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:36PM (#10622552)
Open source drivers are critical for the long term maturation of gaming.

Part of the reason that graphics APIs stagnated for a decade was because vendors were using the API in place of actual technical documentation for their hardware.

If we had a vibrant compiler community for GPUs the same way we do for CPUs we would see the development of new and innovative languages to utilize the hardware way better than the C style imperative or C++ style objects we got stuck with in GLSL / HLSL.

APIs like Vulkan are still frontloading the workload of implementing a software stack to compile for specific hardware targets on the hardware vendors. Meanwhile, CPU compilers have been predominantly community projects that target architectures and we have gotten tech like LLVM out of it.

If we ever want to see the ultimate maturation of massively parallel computing devices, they need to be liberated. That doesn't actually mean free software drivers, but it does mean ISA documentation and programming manuals like the computers they are. Nvidia is antithetical to that future with their current extreme hostility to documenting their hardware.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by witty_username on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:55AM (#10621415)
My personal experience with open source drivers versus Catalyst is that Catalyst is generally buggier (Xorg takes 20% memory at times (memory leak)) while the open source drivers work perfectly and have similar FPS (haven't done benchmarks, but it can't be more than 10-20%).
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by rockdoe on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @08:32AM (#10620569)
The (old, "radeon") open source AMD drivers are good enough for a bunch of Steam games, including popular ones like CS:GO or Dota2. Unfortunately they don't scale with higher end cards having the same performance as old ones.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by Shorel on Thursday November 26, 2015 @12:30PM (#10633881)
> Open source drivers are meaningless for gaming

Not in principle. See Intel drivers for example. They will not beat a desktop AMD or nVidia card, but I can play Mark of the Ninja and many other games here in my Ubuntu laptop without issues.

I can't play Portal 2 in the laptop with good framerates, but demanding games are not the only games in town.

Therefore, open source drivers matter.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by rigid_dreams on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:37AM (#10621779)
> you can't use them for gaming no more than you can use the OSS Geforce ones

Completely wrong