Re:Cyber Spying Is Out, Cyber Lying Is In
by delinka on Monday November 23, 2015 @11:12PM
(#10619098)
How do digital signatures solve the problem? The manipulator of the data just re-signs the new manipulated data. If you're suggesting that equipment (smartphones, DV cameras) sign their outputs, you still can't trust the signature-- How do you force the original signature to remain attached? How do you prevent anyone from faking some other device key and producing a new signature? This is effectively a problem related to the DRM realm, and DRM has failed to thwart pirates.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Cyber Spying Is Out, Cyber Lying Is In
by CyberDildonics on Monday November 23, 2015 @11:15PM
(#10619108)
Leaps in logic to DRM and piracy aside, if you trust that you have the correct public key for a source, someone else's signature is not going to match the original key.
Re:Cyber Spying Is Out, Cyber Lying Is In
by bcoates on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:26AM
(#10619269)
It's not much of a leap; both depend on trusting potentially attacker-controlled devices. If my sensor drone signs reports it sends back a remotely exploited drone could send back validly signed tampered data.
Re:Cyber Spying Is Out, Cyber Lying Is In
by brownbat on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:44AM
(#10619312)
Exactly.
It's not a sheep vs. goats problem, where you just have to ID those bad machines and block them.
It's a defector problem. Any 'legitimate' machine can join a botnet at any moment, along with all the permissions and trust you vested it with back when you approved of whatever it was doing.