News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Misa: a digital guitar by sliverstorm on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:17AM (#1061747)
Wow, this is really cool... but I am not so sure I look forward to the day things like this become mainstream.

It'd be SO easy to fake even ridiculously complex performances, as by design you can offload a lot of the skill onto the computer inside your guitar!

But, then again I suppose this is the same problem we have always had, and always will have- computers vs. art and creativity.

Re:Misa: a digital guitar by ryanwaggoner on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:27AM (#1061756)
But, then again I suppose this is the same problem we have always had, and always will have- computers vs. art and creativity.

This is a false dilemma; computers and technology enable true producers and artists to do more amazing things. The poseurs will get wrapped up the technology and try to use it to paper over their lack of creativity, but the real artists will find a way to harness it. Look at Pixar.

Re:Misa: a digital guitar by devin on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @05:53AM (#1061878)
I agree with you but I do sympathise with one creative dilemma I've run into over and over again with digital music.

The number of options you have is overwhelming. On a certain level I appreciate the number of options I'm afforded. On the other hand I feel like 'tweaking this' and 'changing that' takes a front seat, and the actual production of something worthwhile gets left behind.

Take a look at all of the overproduced albums you hear these days. It's not digital music's fault-- but it's a common problem.

Re:Misa: a digital guitar by voidpointer on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @04:46AM (#1061824)
> It'd be SO easy to fake even ridiculously complex performances

Given the number of full playback performances that are already happening, I don't suppose the faking could get any worse. "Real" musicians will never fake a performance others in the industry will use all means available to them to fake their way to fame and fortune. Both ends of this spectrum are targeting different audiences though.

Re:Misa: a digital guitar by CWuestefeld on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @10:30AM (#1062301)
I recall seeing Jethro Tull back on their Under Wraps tour. I don't recall which song, but one of the tracks from that record features a repeating synth riff. The keyboardist (a hired gun) actually made a bit of a show with this, if you had your eye on him. He recorded the riff into his sequencer in realtime (which I guess should count as "real" rather than "fake") and then stood back and held up his hands as if to say "Look, Ma, no hands".