They're not stripping anything of it's meaning; they're taking things to their logical conclusion. And there's really no way that you can claim the language used for Android development is not Java.
Re:Google Launches Android Studio 2.0
by needusername on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:52AM
(#10619495)
> And there's really no way that you can claim the language used for Android development is not Java.
Even if the language used for Android development is were Java that wouldn't make ART a JVM. JVM is a VM specification that is not tied to the source but the byte code. In several cases (eg. method lookup) there a significant differences between Java and JVM semantics.
The language used for Android development is not Java. Again, there is a precise definition of what Java means (the language specification) and a test to verify what you have is Java (the TCK). ART/Android does not pass that test (it's not even close) and has no intention of doing so. For example Java semantics allow on the fly code generation. AFAIK ART/Android does not support this.
Re:Google Launches Android Studio 2.0
by bitmapbrother on Monday November 23, 2015 @05:02PM
(#10617653)
It's clear you don't understand how the ART VM works so why not research it instead of trying to argue how you think it works.
You are stripping words of their meaning. There is a precise definition of what JVM means. ART isn't close to that and doesn't try to do that. There's nothing wrong with that, just don't call it a JVM.
You can translate Java into JavaScript and run it on a JavaScript VM. This doesn't make that JavaScript VM a JVM.
Pointing out that a language isn't Java simply because it has curly braces isn't straying into pedantry. Pointing out that something isn't ice simply because it is solid isn't straying into pedantry.