Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic
by lhopki01 on Monday November 23, 2015 @10:15AM
(#10614996)
The use of roads is to get people and goods from A to B. If there's a way of doing that that doesn't involve endlessly building roads then do that. Roads are inherently inefficient for moving people around because use about 2 tons of car that takes up a great deal of space to move one person. They're slightly more efficient for goods but even then there are much more efficient ways to move goods most places.
Endless cycle of building an inefficient solution to fix a problem caused by inefficient design is a perfectly valid argument.
And yes the inefficiency was implied by the contrast to public transport investment.
There's lots of constructive arguments to be had about the relative benefits of investment in roads vs. rail vs. whatever, and tons of good criticism to level against subsidies and un-taxed externalities (for all those options). But arguments complaining about the "endless cycle" of building useful things that subsequently get used are silly. This lowers the quality of the conversation about public transit, making it more difficult to convince others of the relative merits.