There's also a packages curriculum problem, which is basically a combination of the problems that exist worth oligopoly educational material regardless of the standards plus the same kind of transitional problems that impact teaching, where people will don't understand the outside of the standards address developing materials to be used under the standards.
Which will likely cause the whole thing to fail, and then we'll be on to the next "revolutionary concept" in education, and the whole mess starts again. Meanwhile, educating real small humans suffers.
First grade stuff is here [0]. Reading through these ideas, I don't really see anything wrong with them other than the standard is clearly written by a committee and is useless for actually doing anything. Very nebulous language that sounds nice and has some good intentions but isn't concrete, as you said. So, as long as we gear these principles appropriately for the abilities of the kids, we should be fine.
So you have to look at the execution. Which is most visible in the avalanche of "look at this bullshit worksheet my kid brought home today" posts that angry parents put up. I think those speak for themselves. As I said, they're often so arbitrary that they make little sense.
[0]: http://www.corestandards.org/Math/Content/1/introduction/
I, too, have been thinking about this a lot. My perspective is as a brand new dad who is sitting here looking at his 11 day old son and wondering how best to educate him. The standards aren't the curriculum, but as far as my son is concerned, what's the difference? It's all a big ball of nastiness that I don't want to expose him to. My wife and I are looking into homeschooling or private education to avoid Common Core and the rest of the insanity that is prevalent in public schools.
> Notice that the second problem is marked incorrect as well. Why is it important that 4 x 6 is 4 rows of 6, instead of 6 rows of 4? Not only does this adhere to the definition, it also teaches students the correct order for diagramming matrices, which is rows times columns.
This sort of slavish devotion to arbitrary conventions is really tiresome, and I think it promotes the wrong sort of thinking about math.
Every time I see one of those questions going around like "4+8÷3(5)=?", it drives me nuts. People look at these equations and point to rules taught in school, or examples in textbooks. They see math as a set of rules, rather than a means of communicating. The fact is, an equation should never be written that way, because as shown by all the arguments about it, the intent of the author is not understood by all readers.
The problem is that these sorts of questions just demand that students mechanically follow a bunch of rules.
"I know it’s frustrating but respect the teachers. They are qualified experts on child education. They have the best intentions for the students in mind. This teacher made a decision based off a lot more information about the student and class setting than we can tell from a photo. We don’t have to agree with it, but we can respect it." ...Why, exactly? Because they're experts?
That's hardly redeemed by the following, "If you are confused, ask them why they did something before you discredit a teacher on the internet."
I have had coworkers, all degreed electrical engineers, show me some of their children's homework and ask me to figure it out, because they couldn't. Similarly, many existing teachers weren't trained in any of this, just told to go do it.
The ideas behind common core are not bad ideas, but the execution has been woeful.
As a parent who has had to deal with these "experts" for years, I can't help rolling my eyes at this nonsense. Respect the teachers? I certainly respect many individual teachers, some of whom are wonderful, but this is a demand that we respect the special expertise of a group that pays politicians enormous sums of money to block any attempt at evaluating that expertise.
I have respect for groups of experts that vigorously weed out all but the top performers from their own ranks and willingly submit themselves to external competition to demonstrate their expertise, not those whose policy instead is to pay lawmakers to prevent anyone from removing the poor performers and to outlaw competitive threats to their monopoly.
Never mind if a child comes in severely behind in reading or math skills and you spend much of the year working to improve those skills. Most teachers actually can't, now, because their state mandates exactly how they will progress through the curriculum. Schools require teachers to file lesson plans. Don't follow the exact content of that lesson plan on a given day, because you find you need to cover something in more detail or cover something the kids already should know, but don't? You might be formally reprimanded if your administration finds out.
My own mother, a career high school economics, accounting, and high-risk (meaning kids whose parents were extremely poor/in jail/other combinations of bad home situations) teacher, always said, "I am here to teach kids, not subjects."
In general, I believe you are correct that most parents who are opposed to the common core also don't understand mathematics, but that's just a symptom of the abysmal way that mathematics is taught[1]. Common core tries to fix this but it falls short because it doesn't actually try to address why children aren't performing well, just gives another way for things to things to go wrong.
[0]: https://medium.com/i-math/why-5-x-3-5-5-5-was-marked-wrong-b...
[1]: https://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/LockhartsLament.... (a classic)