Are you saying that retrograde motion would not be observed from the Sun's perspective?
Re:Orbit of the Moon around the Sun
by ColinWright on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @07:54AM
(#10620396)
Speed of Earth in orbit ~ 150 * 10^9 * 2 * pi / 365.25 / 86400 ~ 30 km/sec
Speed of Moon in orbit ~ 400 * 10^6 * 2 * pi / 27.32 / 86400 ~ 1 km/sec.
Yes, I'm saying that retrograde motion would not be observed from the Sun's perspective.
And then in reply to what you said:
By my way of thinking, this is wrong. Looking at this from the Sun-centric point of view, thinking of the Moon's path in space in the Sun's frame of reference, the path is convex. Take any finite straight line (no, I'm not going to go into General Relativity) whose endpoints are both, at some point, between the Moon and the Sun, then every point on that line is such that it is at some point between the Moon and the Sun.In other words, the path of the Moon is convex. By any common usage of the language, that means it has no loops.