News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by dunkelheit on Sunday November 22, 2015 @01:40PM (#10610935)
While I agree with you, I think I am starting to suffer from a kind of "privacy violation revelations fatigue". I have read the article and thought "so here is another gimmick that steals away a bit of my privacy, so what? no big deal". And that's scary.

The problem is there is no coherent programme on how to counter the privacy-encroachment trend. There is a bit of general dissatisfaction, some idealists urging us to repent and leave the clouds and a good amount of profiteers trying to benefit from that dissatisfaction. Meanwhile the forces behind this trend are organized and powerful.

Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by Frondo on Sunday November 22, 2015 @01:49PM (#10610967)
Another aspect to the problem is that honoring privacy as a human right is a social issue, not a technology issue.

The place to work on solving it (and, like all social issues, it won't be "solved," just "solved for now") is in the public and political spheres. We need to talk about this. We need to have the conversations that describe "what does privacy look like" and "how can we get the benefits from these gadgets while protecting our human rights".

Right now, no one's talking about a world in which you can have your cell phone listening to your conversations, while ensuring that private companies and government agencies can't make use of that willy-nilly. The place where those restrictions have to happen is in the laws we need to develop to keep them all in check.

We can't go back to a primitive, disconnected world, but right now, no one's leading us forward either.

Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by CaptSpify on Sunday November 22, 2015 @02:34PM (#10611135)
> The place where those restrictions have to happen is in the laws we need to develop to keep them all in check.

IMO we need that, but we also can't rely on that. Things like the NSA have shown that the laws don't really matter. Yes, we should be striving for those laws, but we should also not depend on them, when they can so easily be ignored.

Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by nitrogen on Sunday November 22, 2015 @02:37PM (#10611145)
There is a technological aspect, and that's putting the voice processing back into the device itself. We can still get the benefit of mass machine learning on failed voice samples by asking users to submit the failed sample only, playing it back for them so they know what is being sent, and deleting the sample once it has been processed. Then an updated speech model can be sent to the device. Or, just do the retraining on the device, too.
Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by CaptSpify on Sunday November 22, 2015 @02:32PM (#10611131)
> The problem is there is no coherent programme on how to counter the privacy-encroachment trend.

IMO, there sort of is: FOSS

I have my own "Alexa". It uses FOSS, and recognizes simple commands, like: lights off. Play/pause music. Add something to the grocery list.

Unfortunately, it's a lot less feature-full. I really want an Alexa (or the like), but I personally refuse to get one until I can run it on my own servers, and block it from getting on the internet. And unfortunately, that doesn't look like it's gong to happen anytime soon.

I think the big problem is the inability to run these systems without "big data" behind them, and I'm not sure what's the answer to that gap.

Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by dunkelheit on Sunday November 22, 2015 @05:24PM (#10611749)
FOSS is from another era. Back then Microsoft were the bad guys and FOSS was largely a response to their hegemony. Ubuntu bug #1 was "Microsoft has a majority market share" and it is kind of resolved now but increasingly irrelevant. Now it is a different kind of challenge.

True, if you are a geek, you can use open-source software to cobble together some resemblance of popular cloud services but under your own control. There are even detailed guides on how to do it (see also: https://github.com/sovereign/sovereign). But that's a lot of nuisance and in the end what you get is an inferior version.

Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by CaptSpify on Monday November 23, 2015 @11:11AM (#10615352)
> Now it is a different kind of challenge.

Howso? I don't see it as any different, but instead of Microsoft, there are multiple organizations.

> FOSS is from another era. I'm not sure what you mean by this. FOSS is still current, and quite active today. In fact, I'd say even moreso.

> But that's a lot of nuisance and in the end what you get is an inferior version.

I agree. That's what I do now, but it's not nearly as good. But what I was implying was that we have the potential to create a much better version, that's trustworthy.

Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by lukeschlather on Sunday November 22, 2015 @02:41PM (#10611159)
What verifiably private options are there for speech-to-text? It seems like they'd have to be FOSS but most of the "FOSS" solutions I've seen still use a remote server for the actual processing.
Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by walterbell on Sunday November 22, 2015 @02:55PM (#10611217)
It doesn't have to be FOSS, all you need is software designed to run offline, which can be network isolated, e.g. in a virtual machine. Dragon Naturally Speaking (from Nuance) in a Windows VM could perform the speech recognition and relay commands to a Linux VM.

See also the http://www.voxforge.org effort to aggregate OSS acoustic models.

Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by CaptSpify on Sunday November 22, 2015 @03:01PM (#10611247)
> It doesn't have to be FOSS, all you need is software designed to run offline, which can be network isolated, e.g. in a virtual machine.

It depends on who you ask, some people may only be willing to run FOSS stuff |;)

But yeah, I've looked for a "offline: FOSS or not" solution, and haven't found much.

EDIT: I can't reply to you because thread is too deep I'm assuming, but: yeah, it looks like it does. Unfortunately I probably won't try this because it requires windows, and I'm not really wanting to set up a VM/Wine to accomplish this. But you are correct.

Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by walterbell on Sunday November 22, 2015 @03:10PM (#10611283)
Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by CaptSpify on Sunday November 22, 2015 @03:00PM (#10611233)
> What verifiably private options are there for speech-to-text?

Unfortunately not a lot. That's why I said it was "sort of" and answer.

I've tried http://julius.osdn.jp/en_index.php and https://github.com/cmusphinx/pocketsphinx in the past, with very limited results. Though it's been a while and they may have gotten better.

Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by d23 on Sunday November 22, 2015 @02:58PM (#10611230)
> While I agree with you, I think I am starting to suffer from a kind of "privacy violation revelations fatigue". I have read the article and thought "so here is another gimmick that steals away a bit of my privacy, so what? no big deal". And that's scary.

Is it though? To be honest, this article is pretty light on substance. I read through it all because the guy is a good writer, but the only revelation here is him realizing the microphone device he put in his kitchen is... gasp, listening to him.

If it turned out Amazon was actually recording and storing everything, that would be quite the revelation. If it turned out your data wasn't being deleted when Amazon said it was, that would be quite the revelation. Otherwise, there's just not a lot here other than a semi-humorous story about accidentally insulting a robot.

Re:Goodbye privacy, hello Alexa: Amazon Echo, the home robot... by dunkelheit on Sunday November 22, 2015 @05:07PM (#10611682)
Sure, there is nothing of substance revealed in the article, but still the gist is that we should be vaguely concerned. My point is that I am tired of being vaguely concerned.