Every time someone decides to trade some of their privacy for some convenience, they are taking away other people's privacy too, including those of us who do not share the view that it's worth it for the convenience.
People in certain secure facilities or attorneys in many courtrooms weren't allowed to bring in phones with cameras because of respect for the privacy/security of the information and people within.
Now there are no phones without cameras and the insistence on privacy in many of these facilities has been relaxed to saying "please don't take pictures". Not because it's not important, but because of consumer decisions on the whole demanding cameras, to the point where they are in every viable option and it's not feasible to ban them. And privacy/security are eroded.
So when you make a consumer choice like this you're giving our society a tiny little push in that direction. You're pushing always-on always-recording voice monitoring software in the most intimate places of our lives to become the new norm.
If enough people put in listening devices that report to third parties in their homes, that can shift what is a reasonably expectation of privacy to where the government can put listening devices in homes without a warrant.
There was a good essay on this a while back by Alex Kozinski, the chief judge of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals: http://www.stanfordlawreview.org/online/privacy-paradox/dead...
Spoiler warning: that contains a major spoiler for the terrific Isaac Asimov short story "The Dead Past".
Edit: I'm not allowed to answer any more questions right now, sorry to Pyxl101 and others. Hacker News tells me "you are submitting too fast, please slow down". Maybe I'll be able to come back later and answer your questions.
I see that your company plans to "build[] an open platform for atmospheric data collection using smartphone sensors". It looks like you support Apple and advertise their products on your company's website: https://www.pressurenet.io/blog/iphone-6-has-barometer/
"We’re excited to start including iPhones in our study of the atmosphere!"
If you believe that "every purchase[] is a signal", then what signal are you sending about Apple iPhones?
I have not researched it in detail, but it seems like you're relying on data collection from large networks of smartphones in order to put together accurate weather forecasts. That's cool! But I find it hard to reconcile with the view that smartphone data collection (from people who volunteer to participate, or who use a product that has a collection feature) is invasive.
This is sort of a cheap shot but I am honestly curious, how do you reconcile this point of view with your goal of building an all seeing barometer?
It's a difficult line, of course. My goals are to reduce the effects of global climate change by better understanding the atmosphere. If we can provide more accurate wind speed information to wind farms, more accurate solar irradiation information to agriculture businesses, etc, then we can radically improve the world's preparedness for large scale global climate change.
For me, the issue here is deciding which problem is more important to work on. Mitigation of disastrous effects of climate change, or choose to not use any sensor data from smartphones due to my privacy concerns. So far I have aired on the side of climate change being a bigger problem, and that I have a helpful set of work that can make a difference, so I will do my work and hope that it helps.
> When we have a society that so willingly accepts and even desires to live in a surveillance state, well, that's a problem. This is a direct path to a totalitarian surveillance state that would be much much more invasive than anything written about in 1984.
The cognitive dissonance in these two sentences is staggering.