The first 12 years of my education actively sabotaged the latter at the expense of the former. That was wrong. Humans are poor symbol-manipulation machines, and I'm ecstatic the math classes aren't treating them as such anymore.
I have to question this. Humans seem to be natural symbol-manipulation machines. We use this skill all the time in language (spoken early in childhood, written later).
100 years ago we were probably the best symbol-manipulation machines around. We learned to build better ones than us, and now we're pretty poor when compared to such machines.
My son has neither developed a solid understanding of the concepts that common core emphasizes nor a more mechanical ability to manipulate arithmetic expressions.
My anecdotal observation is that most kids at that age are not quite ready to absorb many of the concepts emphasized.
Instead they require gaining some familiarity of the basic elements of arithmetic and what they represent before pulling them apart more.
It gets better in second grade. Our daughter has two timed tests a week that are just cranking through addition and subtraction. It's most likely in preparation for the first MCAS math tests they'll take next year in third grade, but I like them practicing straight up math problems.
There is still the focus on doing the problem just like they were taught, and taking points off for not drawing counters. There is still the work involved in figuring out how the concepts are described so I can help her do the homework.
But it did get a little better, at least for us.
So how is this really better? I'm not getting it.
Emphasizing understanding at the expense of mechanics for basic arithmetic skills is a mistake. Especially, for kids at that age who are just beginning to develop these cognitive skills.
In addition, like the poster, glesica, mentioned below, the questions are often vague and tricky word problems where most of the work is just guessing what they are asking.
My son hasn't actually learned any arithmetic skills beyond what he learned in kindergarten.
Maybe it works better as kids get a bit older but I have found it to be a disaster.