Doesn't the ATM offer a unique challenge each time? Would it matter if the skimmer knew what challenge had been made and what the answer was?
I don't know exactly how it's implemented (tptacek and cperciva would probably have a field day with it) but I think the idea is to prevent exactly such replay attacks by generating the challenge on the bank's central servers.
Hm, should I glue a strip of tinfoil on the magnetic strip? Or what would be a good way to disable it?
A magnetic card writer should definitely do the trick...
True, but then I would lose the option to use it at the few places where they don't understand the chip yet. Might be the better choice, though.
Thinking a bit further, perhaps it would be possible to create some fake information on the magnet stripe that would identify anybody who uses it as a thief?
Yeah, I'm not seriously recommending you reprogram your bank card... Maybe you could strap an alternative magnetic strip to the card, which you'd only take off if you really need the real strip.
The smartcard mechanism hopefully uses some challenge-response setup that makes it impossible to read out by scammers. (aside from the difficulty of interfacing with the chip during the split second it's in the right position)