Re:What Happens When You Can’t Talk to Yourself?
by neltnerb on Saturday November 21, 2015 @02:16PM
(#10607697)
I'm incredibly thankful I don't have this most of the time, but just a few days ago I got one of my occasional migraines where I get temporarily a type of aphasia that makes it so I can't remember a word other than to know the sounds coming out of my mouth are not correct, I can't parse written language, and I forget a lot of words.
It's fascinating to me because it lasts only 22 minutes, but man is it incredibly frustrating. Being intermittently aphasic is really fascinating intellectually though because I can feel/watch as the part of the brain you're describing is temporarily shut down or working improperly.
I can often say one or two words and then eight of gibberish, knowing exactly what I intended to say (in meaning, but with no valid internal monologue) but the words just coming out garbled. I can focus really hard and make a specific sound, but I can't do things like "awk" because it's too complex of a physical motion to make with my jaw and tongue. I can basically intentionally make baby sounds, occasionally a word escapes as intended, but mostly it's just bizarre obviously wrong sounds -- slightly different each time I say the word but mostly similar.
Brains and language are really weird.
With regard to your comment about thinking without monologue, I tried doing that for about a year by using some meditation techniques since it seemed like an interesting idea to avoid "mistranslation" of an idea I fully grok already into language. I'm now convinced that what happens when I talk it through to myself is that data compression is occurring that lets me store a lower fidelity, but longer lasting and more communicatable version of the concept. My memory suffered a lot that year, and many of the concepts were fully lost.
It's fascinating to me because it lasts only 22 minutes, but man is it incredibly frustrating. Being intermittently aphasic is really fascinating intellectually though because I can feel/watch as the part of the brain you're describing is temporarily shut down or working improperly.
I can often say one or two words and then eight of gibberish, knowing exactly what I intended to say (in meaning, but with no valid internal monologue) but the words just coming out garbled. I can focus really hard and make a specific sound, but I can't do things like "awk" because it's too complex of a physical motion to make with my jaw and tongue. I can basically intentionally make baby sounds, occasionally a word escapes as intended, but mostly it's just bizarre obviously wrong sounds -- slightly different each time I say the word but mostly similar.
Brains and language are really weird.
With regard to your comment about thinking without monologue, I tried doing that for about a year by using some meditation techniques since it seemed like an interesting idea to avoid "mistranslation" of an idea I fully grok already into language. I'm now convinced that what happens when I talk it through to myself is that data compression is occurring that lets me store a lower fidelity, but longer lasting and more communicatable version of the concept. My memory suffered a lot that year, and many of the concepts were fully lost.