News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Be a Lawyer Without Going to Law School by snowwrestler on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:16PM (#10607311)
While the bar exam enforces a certain quality of knowledge, it also enforces breadth. Every lawyer in a given jurisdiction takes the same bar exam, and it covers all aspects of the law.

The programming equivalent would be like forcing coders to demonstrate competency in everything from embedded systems programming to OS development to packaged application to web back-end, to web front-end, mobile apps, algorithms, networking, language design, compiler optimization, etc.

The way it works now, coders can specialize and that makes it easier to self-study. Learning all about web front-end dev is a lot easier then learning about every type of programming there is.

If you want credentialling, it would have to be more like medicine, where people have to pass the boards in their specialty only.

Re:How to Be a Lawyer Without Going to Law School by unimpressive on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:19PM (#10607324)
I think you've fallen victim to poe's law. In fairness the parent comment gave few enough hints at satire that I'll need to see the author confirm they did or didn't mean it before I'm convinced either way.
Re:How to Be a Lawyer Without Going to Law School by HillaryBriss on Saturday November 21, 2015 @04:07PM (#10608030)
Thank you for the feedback. I was attempting sarcasm.

My hope was that the line "It's the only way we can reduce the number of data breaches and crashes" would seem immediately ridiculous to everyone.

Given the history of surprising security bugs in mature code being discovered by a decentralized collection of users and hackers over long periods of time -- a phenomenon we've all witnessed over the years -- I figured the notion that a slow-moving, bureaucratic supreme panel of code judges effectively and decisively removing security problems basically didn't make sense.

I don't know now. Maybe it makes more sense than I thought.

Re:How to Be a Lawyer Without Going to Law School by snowwrestler on Sunday November 22, 2015 @12:50AM (#10609216)
I think most programmers today take it on faith that the lightly regulated, free wheeling nature of programming is an inherent, unchangeable, and desirable state.

But if you look back at the history of highly-regulated technology industries, every single one started out lightly regulated and free wheeling. Early railroad, automobile, oil drilling, aviation, and telecommunication companies (to name a few) were all full of self-taught innovators who wanted to move fast and disrupt things.

As software eats the world, the world will become less and less tolerant of shitty software. I will not be surprised at all to see demand for credentialling and oversight grow even in the next 10 years.

Re:How to Be a Lawyer Without Going to Law School by techbio on Saturday November 21, 2015 @08:01PM (#10608645)
That checks out.