News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by rayiner on Saturday November 21, 2015 @11:45AM (#10607204)
Most people owed pensions are solidly middle class. They are way better off than the young people who will be paying for them.

And blaming the financial sector for the pension crisis is ridiculous. States and municipalities entered into very risky financial arrangements because for years they made very optimistic actuarial assumptions about pension fund growth, and committed to benefits that could not be sustained once population growth plateaued.

Investing in those risky assets was a gambit to get the kind of returns they needed to stay solvent. That gambit failed, but financial companies didn't create the underfunding that led to the need to invest in risky assets in the first place.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by DanielBMarkham on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:13PM (#10607295)
You and crdoconnor are eloquently demonstrating the damage debt does to discourse.

Whatever your political slant, in this case it looks like class warfare, it can be turned against itself when debt starts limiting the degrees of freedom political action can take. Conservatives will do the same thing -- for them the argument will be something like "if we can't fund the national defense/LE, why do we need a government in the first place?"

Long term, this debt problem, whether local or national, is some nasty, radioactive stuff.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by toomuchtodo on Saturday November 21, 2015 @03:06PM (#10607853)
Wouldn't this suggest that a better pension system would be identical to social security? Where payroll revenue is quickly distributed to pensioners?

That's the problem, isn't it. If you can use debt or a surplus to game the system, everyone loses at someone else's benefit.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by morgante on Saturday November 21, 2015 @06:43PM (#10608495)
A better system would be to let people save in their own individual retirement accounts.

If you want to force companies to support retirement, force them to pay into employee's retirement accounts.

The benefit of individual accounts is that they're a lot harder to raid or defund.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by toomuchtodo on Saturday November 21, 2015 @10:59PM (#10609026)
Except when financial firms skim off of personal accounts with excessive fees. Or the fact that Social Security exists as a form of social insurance in the event you're unable to save enough or lose all of your retirement funds.

Your idea of only individual retirement accounts is a terrible one.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by tptacek on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:52AM (#10614279)
I hate fees as much as everyone else does, but excessive fees are not the reason so many individual retirement accounts fail.
Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by toomuchtodo on Monday November 23, 2015 @01:14PM (#10616123)
I don't disagree with you. My thesis is, it would be a terrible idea to switch pension systems like social security to individual accounts you're responsible for and could liquidate. That is not how insurance works!
Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by morgante on Sunday November 22, 2015 @04:47AM (#10609603)
> Except when financial firms skim off of personal accounts with excessive fees.

Uh, then choose a different financial firm? I have $100k+ in my brokerage and pay about $10 a year in fees...

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by crdoconnor on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:55PM (#10607442)
>Most people owed pensions are solidly middle class.

The middle class is gone.

>They are way better off than the young people who will be paying for them.

As opposed to the oligarchs who are trying to leech wealth from both groups?

>And blaming the financial sector for the pension crisis is ridiculous.

Did you read the link? What happened to Detroit was looting and fraud. Plain and simple.

>States and municipalities entered into very risky financial arrangements because for years they made very optimistic actuarial assumptions about pension fund growth

Optimistic == We assumed that interest rates would not be dropped to zero to bail out the financial sector. This was a reasonable actuarial assumption pre-2008 and it should have been a reasonable actuarial assumption post-2008.

>Investing in those risky assets

Investing in those risky assets largely happened after the government decided to drop interest rates to zero in order to bail out the banks. Much of it was also driven by un-prosecuted fraud.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by tptacek on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:53AM (#10614283)
California and Illinois pension plans were disasters before the financial crisis, so your argument doesn't have much explanatory power.