News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Be a Lawyer Without Going to Law School by codingdave on Saturday November 21, 2015 @10:49AM (#10607041)
I don't think law school can be fairly characterized as not being self-study. Admittedly, I only went for one year before deciding I did not want to go that route, but it was more like: "Here, go teach yourself this stack of cases tonight. I am going to rip your self-study to shreds in the morning."
Re:How to Be a Lawyer Without Going to Law School by geebee on Saturday November 21, 2015 @10:53AM (#10607054)
There are degrees of "self-taught". There are programmers who majored in CS and stay up on the field, programmers who majored in math and worked their way through the algorithms book, programmers with no degree at all. As a math major, I guess I'll just punt and say the relationship between this and self-directed learning in law school "is left as an exercise for the reader". I do tend to agree with you that all learning ultimately is self directed, though again, that takes different forms.

Here's the thing - if formally enrolling in law school can't be characterized as "not self study", what can be? We'd be striking the phrase from the language at that point. So while I agree that all learning is self-directed to an extent, I do think it's reasonable to say that programmers do tend to be more "self-taught" than lawyers.

Re:How to Be a Lawyer Without Going to Law School by codingdave on Saturday November 21, 2015 @11:41AM (#10607188)
Oh, definitely coders are more self-taught, if we want to jump to that question. I was pointing out that law school is more of a progression through a self-taught curriculum than other formal educational pursuits. (After which you get to self-study for the bar exam.)

In context of the original article, being mentored by a practicing lawyer is likely to be similar to law school in the amount of self-study, so the idea that programmers would prefer one mechanism over another due solely to self-study is not a premise that I agree with.

Re:How to Be a Lawyer Without Going to Law School by noblethrasher on Saturday November 21, 2015 @10:55AM (#10607058)
>I am going to rip your self-study to shreds in the morning.

Which is what compilers, interpreters, and "Show HN" do.

Re:How to Be a Lawyer Without Going to Law School by HillaryBriss on Saturday November 21, 2015 @11:39AM (#10607181)
And real world users
Re:How to Be a Lawyer Without Going to Law School by wutangson1 on Saturday November 21, 2015 @01:13PM (#10607494)
pretty much the most accurate description of law school I've seen.