News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA Orders SpaceX Crew Mission to International Space St... by fivesigma on Friday November 20, 2015 @06:39PM (#10604615)
A 160km altitude cubesat would require a minimum 7.8km/s of delta-v. Anything less than that and it will burn up in the atmosphere after a few orbits. GoFast Rocket achieved a top speed of 1.6 km/s (3580 mph).

It needs to go 4 times faster, and no, a 20% larger rocket won't cut it. 20000% larger by mass would be more like it. It also needs a 2nd stage burning liquid propellant with high specific impulse which is way, way harder to build than a dumb solid propellant rocket.

Noone (not even governments) has been able to send a single stage rocket to orbit.

Re:NASA Orders SpaceX Crew Mission to International Space St... by dogma1138 on Friday November 20, 2015 @06:53PM (#10604675)
Israel and India use 3 stage HTPB solid rockets for space launches you don't need to have a 2nd stage liquid fuel rocket to get to orbit.

Also 20000% larger by mass? want to be a bit more serious? if you scale this rocket by 35-40% you get to about the size of the first stage of the Shavit solid fuel space launcher which is a commercial space launcher.

You do understand how scaling works on 3 dimensional objects right?

Re:NASA Orders SpaceX Crew Mission to International Space St... by fivesigma on Friday November 20, 2015 @07:10PM (#10604750)
10000% by mass is a more accurate figure and since you like dimensional scaling, that's 364% scaling.

The GoFast Rocket weighs 350kg. Scaling it by 35% (1.35 ^ 3) would make it weigh 861kg. The rocket you mentioned weighs between 30 and 70 _tons_.

I'm not sure you understand how anything works.

Re:NASA Orders SpaceX Crew Mission to International Space St... by simoncion on Friday November 20, 2015 @08:19PM (#10605008)
> I'm not sure you understand how anything works.

Based on my previous conversations with this guy, this seems to be a recurring pattern. I do hope that he's using these conversations to recognize and fill in the holes in his knowledge. :)

Re:NASA Orders SpaceX Crew Mission to International Space St... by mikeash on Friday November 20, 2015 @07:15PM (#10604778)
What good does it do to scale something up to the size of the first stage of a four stage rocket? Those other three stages are pretty important to that whole putting-stuff-in-orbit business.

Edit: I see Shavit can also launch in a three stage configuration. My overall point remains.