Re:NASA Orders SpaceX Crew Mission to International Space St...
by dogma1138 on Friday November 20, 2015 @06:51PM
(#10604661)
Yes I understand it quite well, ~20% scale up which is 20% longer, and 20% wider is quite a big change in mass.
The big problem is either staging or being able to shift it to a shallow enough trajectory and get enough velocity, but it might be solvable if you can do a zoom climb type launch from an aircraft similar to how Pegasus/SpaceShip One do it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pegasus_(rocket)
Re:NASA Orders SpaceX Crew Mission to International Space St...
by mikeash on Friday November 20, 2015 @07:06PM
(#10604736)
How is a 20% scale up going to get you anywhere close to the extra dv needed? 20% on each dimension is still only 70% more rocket, where you need something more like 10x more rocket to make that leap.
Re:NASA Orders SpaceX Crew Mission to International Space St...
by lutorm on Friday November 20, 2015 @08:30PM
(#10605053)
That's 1.2^3, or 70% more... not even close. Also remember that making the rocket bigger also increases the dry mass, which further increases the fuel requirements.
The difference in ISP between a liquid-fueled rocket (say 450s for LH2/LO2, 350s for RP1/LO2) and solid propellant (250s) makes a huge difference to your prop fraction. To get, say 8km/s delta-v, just plug it into the rocket equation:
LH2/LO2: 6.1 initial/final mass. RP1/LO2: 10.3 solids: 26
Staging can help this a bit, but the basic fact remains. It's very difficult to get useful payload to orbit with solids.
Altitude is the easy part, relatively speaking. Getting the speed for LEO is the hard part. The GoFast rocket you linked to has demonstrated up to 4,200MPH. Low earth orbit requires about 17,000MPH.
That factor of ~4 requires massively larger rockets, because the rocket equation is cruel. Each incremental increase in final speed requires an exponential (actually using this word correctly, for once) increase in the amount of fuel. Fuel in return requires more hardware like tanks and engines, which means yet more fuel is required, etc.
Edit: using RP-1 as the fuel in a single stage, getting to 4,200MPH requires that 45% of your total rocket mass be fuel at launch. Getting to LEO requires 94% of the mass to be fuel.