That one is pretty close to the slippery slopes that lead into Brave New World-style dystopia, Brazil-style dystopia, Walden Two-style dystopia, Atlas Shrugged-style dystopia, and Snow Crash-style dystopia.
We're damned if we do, damned if we don't, and doubly-damned if we do it half-assed.
So good for the EFF, and their noble effort to steer the train.
On the contrary, I find the EFF one of the few groups of optimists.
They're not, like, supervillains.
When I was much younger (in my late teens), I worked with prosecutors on a case in Seattle --- pro bono, not for money. It was such a bad experience that I wound up going on strike until they sent me a written apology.
All the stories I've ever heard about security people collaborating with prosecutors or the FBI or USSS have been horror stories.
Later: I should add that I don't grant the premise that the FBI uses informants to crack down on political dissidents --- the Hoover-era FBI surely did, but then, the FBI was not the worst part of the politics of the late 60s.
We're very lucky to have the EFF.
EFF does some good things, and some things I think are less good. I think we're luckier to have the ACLU.
I find EFF to be a deeply cynical organization, even though I for the most part share their policy objectives.