News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to lose $5B by SilasX on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:02PM (#10597166)
I think it's the opposite: any org (private or public) should be required to pre-fund infinite years of benefits. That is, if you're compensating the employee with benefit X, you should book (the ROR-discounted present value of) that full liability now, irrespective of when you would have to eventually pay it. That one extra month of employee work earned them $100, 80 years from now? Great, that should be $0.71 less you have to spend. No 75-year cutoff. (Or 50, or 40, or 25).

Any other arrangement is forcing the employee to become an investor, in which case the usual protections should attach.

No company should be able to play the game of "oh, man, we totally thought we'd be making bank 40 years on, bummer we can't pay the rest of our worker's employment compensation, tough s---." And then you have situations like GM, Bethlehem Steel, etc.

Why is anyone cool with "don't worry, we'll be profitable later" when it comes to worker's wages? Why do people like gambling with workers' promised benefits?

Re:How to lose $5B by crdoconnor on Thursday November 19, 2015 @04:37PM (#10597890)
This used not to be a problem when pension benefits were shifted to the public sector (which doesn't have a solvency problem by definition).

Nonetheless, neoliberal dogma says that the market does a better job of investing than the government will.

Coincidentally privatized pension contributions provide ample opportunity for profiteering.

It's more that we let this happen to us through inaction rather than we asked for it, though.

Re:How to lose $5B by SilasX on Thursday November 19, 2015 @04:55PM (#10598004)
>This used not to be a problem when pension benefits were shifted to the public sector (which doesn't have a solvency problem by definition).

There is no definition of public sector that makes bankruptcy impossible.

Pre-funding is about honesty of the obligations. If you say you're going to pay the workers $X at time t, apportion the money now. Put your full faith and credit behind it now. Make it so you can only renege by reneging on bonds in general.

It's mind-boggling how ostensibly pro-worker advocates are okay with the mentality of, "don't worry, we'll find your pension money later, if Congress appropriates enough down the road".

Re:How to lose $5B by crdoconnor on Thursday November 19, 2015 @06:48PM (#10598546)
>There is no definition of public sector that makes bankruptcy impossible.

The US treasury can't and won't ever run out of dollars. Whenever there is a bank that needs bailing out or a war suddenly the government remembers this. It's only when funding pension obligations or healthcare it suddenly 'forgets' and assumes that taxes pay for things.

There is still an inflation risk but bankruptcy does indeed become impossible.

>Pre-funding is about honesty of the obligations. If you say you're going to pay the workers $X at time t, apportion the money now. Put your full faith and credit behind it now. Make it so you can only renege by reneging on bonds in general.

There has to be wiggle room somewhere if it's a private sector obligation. Pension are invested and future payouts are based upon certain assumptions about those investments holding. A lot of perfectly reasonable assumptions pre-2008 suddenly went out of the window afterwards.

So it is not entirely about honesty of the obligations.

>It's mind-boggling how ostensibly pro-worker advocates are okay with the mentality of, "don't worry, we'll find your pension money later, if Congress appropriates enough down the road".

I've never heard any ostensibly pro worker advocate say this.

Re:How to lose $5B by SilasX on Thursday November 19, 2015 @07:05PM (#10598641)
>The US treasury can't and won't ever run out of dollars.

Again, the point is that dynamic is unrelated to the definition of the public sector. I understand the on-the-ground reality; I was objecting to your characterizing of it as "by definition".

>There has to be wiggle room somewhere if it's a private sector obligation. Pension are invested and future payouts are based upon certain assumptions about those investments holding. A lot of perfectly reasonable assumptions pre-2008 suddenly went out of the window afterwards.

Right, but there's a big difference between "our reasonable RoR estimates were a little off and we unexpectedly needed to add a little more this year" vs "we never funded it to begin with and expected to earn the income to fund this later".

Funding it now makes the promise honest; "we'll find the money later" isn't, and it's wrong for GM or the USPS to do this. For the US government, the promises need to go right into the federal debt, which the 75-year prefund obligation would accomplish.

>I've never heard any ostensibly pro worker advocate say this.

You did, when you advocated the USPS handle its pensions that way, not having to prefund them (modulo time/RoR discount).

Re:How to lose $5B by dragonwriter on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:09PM (#10597225)
> I think it's the opposite: any org (private or public) should be required to pre-fund infinite years of benefits.

This position is not unreasonable. OTOH, it is unreasonable to require the USPS to prefund benefits that neither private businesses nor government agencies are required to prefund, specifically to make its finances look bad when compared with other entities.

Re:How to lose $5B by SilasX on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:23PM (#10597340)
Is it reasonable to scream bloody murder when one org is forced to follow the sane policy instead of demanding that others start to follow it too?
Re:How to lose $5B by dragonwriter on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:25PM (#10597362)
> Is it reasonable to scream bloody murder when one org is forced to follow the sane policy instead of demanding that others start to follow it too?

I disagree that it is a sane policy (much less that it is the sane policy) except when applied consistently. There is a not-unreasonable argument that it might be a sane policy, applied consistently.

Re:How to lose $5B by danharaj on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:06PM (#10597197)
I don't see why this logic does not equally apply to debt and financing, which are the structural foundation of capitalism.
Re:How to lose $5B by sophacles on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:10PM (#10597235)
I think there is an aweful lot of handwaving that goes on...

Largely the justification for owners of equity get rewarded for taking a risk, and the employees get wages less than the full value of their output because they take no risk. If they are taking no risk, then any pension plan should also be risk free, not a hidden tie-in to the risk used to justify their pay.

Re:How to lose $5B by SilasX on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:08PM (#10597219)
I answered that here:

>>Any other arrangement is forcing the employee to become an investor, in which case the usual protections should attach.

The return is speculative? Then you're an investor. The return is part of your promised compensation package? It shouldn't be (modulo the ability to predict reasonable RoRs, etc.)