The entire point is to bankrupt the company immediately. If the fine can be included as a cost of doing business, its not effective.
The question is, can you devise a method where if the employer does everything right in verifying someone's right to work in the country, they won't be held liable? That's the trick. To squeeze out any chance of fraud on either side, with damning consequences for breaking the rules (I'd also accept criminal liability for those involved in lieu of bankrupting a concern).
A fine that is equal to the wages saved should create an incentive to pay at least that wage. Perhaps also give half of the fine to anyone, including an undocumented worker, who chooses to report the violation.
Again, I don't believe that's going to incentivize legal behavior. It's too low.
10x wages saved, directly paid to the undocumented worker might be the way to go.