News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by iamthepieman on Thursday November 19, 2015 @09:34AM (#10594948)
I wonder what this will do to the short term evolution of our species.

It's terribly morbid and I really don't think it will come to this but if many people start dying due to once easily treatable infections then it could rapidly (within a dozen generations or so) change how our immune system works.

A mass dieoff of a species due to a single catastrophic event is unlikely to intensely select for certain traits.

A flood amonsgst a non-swimming species is as likely to select for resillience or sleeping late in your tree or some other unpredicable attribute as it is for the "swimming" gene

But constant intense pressure could easily single out favorable attributes and I wonder what those will be and what the side effects or emergent traits of those genes will be.

Of course we are evolving via technology and society more rapidly than genetically so that could change everything.

Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by mrestko on Thursday November 19, 2015 @09:51AM (#10595049)
You mean a return to the wold before antiobiotics? The world that existed when my grandparents were born? I doubt the few generations of people born during the "antibiotic era" have any meaningful genetic traits connected with the use of antibiotics
Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by lucaspiller on Thursday November 19, 2015 @10:29AM (#10595257)
Just to put things into perspective, the world population was around 2 billion when penicillin was discovered in 1928. Even without antibiotics we still know about things like sanitation and the importance of clean drinking water, so it's not exactly going back to the dark ages as the article suggests.
Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by DanBC on Thursday November 19, 2015 @01:56PM (#10596720)
It's going to be pretty bad.

https://publichealthmatters.blog.gov.uk/2015/11/02/i-need-an...

> If we can’t stop the infection, however, we can’t stop the sepsis. A world without effective antibiotics will mean that every one of the 100,000 people who develop sepsis each year in the UK - every one of the 18 million people with sepsis each year worldwide - could certainly die from simple infections like chest and water infections. A human could die from infection every second.

> When I started treating people with bacterial infections it was rare that I didn’t have tablet antibiotics that I could treat them with; rare that I needed to keep people in hospital to treat their infections. Now every week, I treat young women with last resort antibiotics for urinary tract infections. Rather than given them a simple 7-day tablet course, they have to stay in hospital for a week or more, or come to the hospital every day for an injection.

https://publichealthmatters.blog.gov.uk/2014/11/18/10-reason...

> When we discuss antibiotic resistance we talk about a frightening future and rightly ask for action to stop the problem from getting worse. But this doesn't mean it's all just an issue for future generations. It’s estimated that 25,000 people already die every year in Europe because of infections resistant to antibiotics and in the USA the figure is 23,000 people, every year.

https://publichealthmatters.blog.gov.uk/2015/11/18/7-more-re...

> In 2013 there were 480,000 recorded cases of multi drug-resistant TB (TB that can’t be treated by our usual medicines). TB is a bacterial infection that can spread through the lymph nodes and blood stream to any organ in your body. It commonly affects the lungs and while a lot of people might not consider it to be an issue in the UK, or think it couldn’t affect them, this isn’t true. 37 million lives worldwide have been saved by antibiotic treatment for TB since 2000. In some countries, it is becoming increasingly difficult to treat MDR-TB. Treatment options are limited, recommended medicines are not always available, and patients experience many adverse effects from the drugs.

Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by devcpp on Thursday November 19, 2015 @01:41PM (#10596619)
No offense, but did you even read the parent post? The person above clearly points out that a sudden shock may cause more genetic changes through selection than slow deaths.

Such a case has never happened in the past, unless I didn't learn about an antibiotics crisis in ancient Egypt.

Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by iamthepieman on Thursday November 19, 2015 @10:21AM (#10595212)
Yes, you're right of course. But clearly the few generations of the "antibiotic era" have had a much larger effect on the bacteria than us.

We used antibiotic technology to "evolve" resistance to bacteria. Bacteria responded much more rapdily than we could have naturally and is now a different organism than what our grandparents had to contend with. Now our technological "evolution" is unable to keep up with natures and we face a new threat not an old one. One we helped to create.

Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by adventured on Thursday November 19, 2015 @09:55AM (#10595081)
The human race as we know it today, doesn't have dozens of generations. We'll be a radically different species in just 200 to 300 years, through self-controlled evolution that has already begun.

Before the end of this century we'll be directly editing the genome of every child born in the first world. Human evolution is no longer in nature's hands, and it will never be again unless technological progress rolls backwards drastically (at the rate it's accelerating, that is possible but unlikely; it's more likely we're about to achieve lift-off in regards to rapid evolution; if you think CRISPR is interesting, just wait until you see what we have in just 30 years).

Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by ManFromUranus on Thursday November 19, 2015 @10:52AM (#10595393)
>We'll be a radically different species in just 200 to 300 years, through self-controlled evolution that has already begun

We are essentially already doing this. We are selecting for cancer and other disease processes when we cure cancer and other diseases in children who would otherwise have died who then survive to reproduce. It's not polite to say this, but that is what is happening.

Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by mikeash on Thursday November 19, 2015 @12:41PM (#10596151)
Are you really selecting for cancer when you do that, or are you merely no longer selecting against cancer?
Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by marcosdumay on Thursday November 19, 2015 @12:09PM (#10595934)
We've been changing our selection factors for millenniums. Fire and road building had much stronger effects than anything coming from medical procedures today.

Humans are a cybernetic species. Always were.

Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by SCHiM on Thursday November 19, 2015 @11:57AM (#10595852)
But we're also on the cusp of being able to identify and then pre-emptively remove those genes for the gene pool directly via IVF + screening of the embryo to make sure that it doesn't carry any known diseases and/or defects. Even if we don't actively edit a embryo it will still speed up the evolution of our species.
Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by TeMPOraL on Thursday November 19, 2015 @02:31PM (#10596966)
I'd argue that sudden loss of antibiotic effectiveness is something that could roll us back into middle ages. Progress of technology is a powerful engine that seems self-sustaining at this point, but it's mounted to the frame of society - and that frame is very fragile. That's why I personally make such a big deal of this issue, or overreacting to terrorism threats. Because if the frame breaks and the engine halts, it may take many thousands of years to restart it. We've dug up all easily accessible high-density energy sources, so if we find ourselves back in pre-industrial era, it may take a long time to have another industrial revolution.
Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by bad_user on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:01PM (#10597159)
The industrial era is nothing more than subsidised costs by means of fossil fuels and the destruction of our environment, with all progress being made tending to be zero sum. Oh so we discovered antibiotics? Great, but now we have to deal with increasing rates of diabetes, cancer, heart and immunodeficiency diseases. And even though some people would like to make us think that our life expectancy has gone up, that's only true for the average because of increased expectancy at birth. Plus we are not measuring quality of life. You know, the only real progress we've made is in terms of education and individual rights.

I'm actually starting to think that the Industrial Age is the worst thing that could have happened to human kind. Even this antibiotics apocalypse, along with outbreaks of potentially deadly viruses, like the mad cow disease or the aviary flu, are caused by industrial farming practices, which are also guilty of polluting the soil they stand on and the nearby water streams, damaging the area and the people living nearby,

A post-industrial age is long overdue.

Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by TeMPOraL on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:26PM (#10597363)
We had more people leaving much happier lives than ever before in history, so I wouldn't say that "the Industrial Age is the worst thing that could have happened to human kind". Even the most horrible problems of our times are affecting less people than the mundane pre-industrial problems were. If we can push through it to a post-industrial technological era, then it'll definitely be worth it.
Re:World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era' by VanillaLime on Thursday November 19, 2015 @06:00PM (#10598302)
There are many, many places on earth where you can go and live precisely the lifestyle that the vast majority lived before the Industrial Age. Assuming you live in the US, there are literally tens of millions of acres of land in the West around the Rockies where you can live completely away from modern industry. Grow your own food, build your own cabin, never touch modern medicine.

If you really feel that all progress for the past thousand years has been worthless, go ahead and live a life from a thousand years ago. I'm pretty sure it will take you less a month to realize that life sucked back then.