News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DRM in TIG welders by jordanb on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @06:41PM (#10591573)
Your examples of changing weapons to be untraceable or more lethal are not apropos because these are violations of legal restrictions passed by congress into law.

You can not saw off a shotgun not because Browning doesn't want you to saw it off, but because sawed off shotguns are not legal.

What the DMCA does is take a manufacturer's prerogative and elevate it to the status of federal crime as soon as the manufacturer decides to create a "digital rights management" scheme to enforce that prerogative.

Re:DRM in TIG welders by DannyBee on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @07:29PM (#10591838)
"Your examples of changing weapons to be untraceable or more lethal are not apropos because these are violations of legal restrictions passed by congress into law. "

So is the DMCA?

I'm not understanding what distinction you are making. They became federal crimes identically.

"You can not saw off a shotgun not because Browning doesn't want you to saw it off, but because sawed off shotguns are not legal."

I'm not sure how this is relevant, particularly? What relevance does who wants you to not touch your property matter to your notion you should free to do with your property what you want.

"What the DMCA does is take a manufacturer's prerogative and elevate it to the status of federal crime as soon as the manufacturer decides to create a "digital rights management" scheme to enforce that prerogative. " I'm quite aware of what the DMCA says (and in fact, have been directly involved in pushing back on large numbers of crappy DMCA requests).

I'm trying to understand why you think this is special somehow, compared to all the other things that folks have made it illegal to do with your property, which span the gamut from government saying you can't do this directly, to government saying you can't do what this other guy says you can't do, to etc.

Re:DRM in TIG welders by jordanb on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @08:40PM (#10592184)
The DMCA's anti-circumvention language constitutes a delegation of congressional power to private manufacturers, who can create schemes at will to criminalize uses of their products which they consider to be harmful to their business.
Re:DRM in TIG welders by DannyBee on Sunday November 22, 2015 @02:56PM (#10611221)
"The DMCA's anti-circumvention language constitutes a delegation of congressional power to private manufacturers, who can create schemes at will to criminalize uses of their products which they consider to be harmful to their business. " ?????

No it literally does not. You make it sound like they choose what is circumvention and not, and they don't. Congress did. You are really stretching here to try to differentiate it. You'd be much better off saying "it's not different, but it still sucks", because right now, your argument strongly stretches credulity IMHO.