News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's iTunes Is Alienating Its Most Music-Obsessed Users by tptacek on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @11:00AM (#10588407)
iTunes is a tire fire. But purely in terms of content, Apple Music is probably the best streaming service, and their recommendation system is getting better. Apple also has the benefit of iTunes/Apple Music being closer to a first-class citizen on things like car bluetooth audio systems.

I would be thrilled to hear that Apple is totally revamping iTunes; I swear at it at least a couple times a week. But I'm probably not going to be able to stop using it any time soon.

I'm not sure I really understand the people who use alternate music player software on OS X; huge collections of downloaded music files accessed through file player software doesn't seem like where digital music is headed. I had a gigantic collection of purchased music on my computer, and it's more an annoyance now than anything else.

Hating iTunes so much you can't use it makes sense to me. But then, why not just use Spotify?

Anyways: predicting where this thread is inevitably heading, here's a list off the top of my head of shit that drives me nuts about iTunes:

* Purchased tracks randomly grey out and become non-playable.

* I'm a "Match" customer, and iTunes/iCloud/whatever doggedly insists on retaining the file-based metadata from my old MP3s, despite me not having had those MP3s in years.

* Ridiculous incoherent "Playlists / For You / New / Radio / Connect / iTunes Store" menu. "For You"?

* Playlists that contain both Apple Music tracks and purchased tracks flake out and vanish, which means that if you have a large collection of purchased music, playlists just don't work.

* Sometimes you can link to a playlist to share it and sometimes you can't.

Re:Apple's iTunes Is Alienating Its Most Music-Obsessed Users by josefresco on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @11:58AM (#10588943)
* Purchased tracks randomly grey out and become non-playable.*

This 1000 times. I've been through three iPhones, and continue to be baffled why some of my music becomes unplayable. I solve by syncing (again and again...), navigating endless menus and changing random values in a vain attempt to find the problem and then hoping, and praying that next time I'm in my car, all my music will be available.

Re:Apple's iTunes Is Alienating Its Most Music-Obsessed Users by banku_brougham on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @12:44PM (#10589322)
Me too. UX hell.
Re:Apple's iTunes Is Alienating Its Most Music-Obsessed Users by kingbathtub on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @11:22AM (#10588633)
re: using an alternate music player

with my 200 GB/ 50k song library, iTunes is absolutely unusable, and I completely abandoned it last year. Apple has crammed so much into iTunes and just bloated the hell out of it, which is unsurprising for a design philosophy that layered all their media services on top of one another.

My replacement has been using Rdio and Swinsian. Rdio lets me stream most of what I have in my library as well as new releases. Swinsian is still necessary for obscure or underground music I've downloaded that aren't available on streaming services, as well as my personal vinyl rips, which make up maybe 1/5 of my library. so while music consumption is definitely moving away from downloaded files to streaming, there are still niche needs for a dedicated file player.

Unfortunately, with the recent news about Rdio, I have no idea what streaming service I'm gonna migrate to. Audio nerds recommend Tidal, my family uses Spotify, so I'll probably give those two and Apple Music a trial spin and evaluate.

Re:Apple's iTunes Is Alienating Its Most Music-Obsessed Users by banku_brougham on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @12:43PM (#10589314)
So Swinsian is listed in the article as the only viable alternative, my problem is its a one-person shop which is a risky bet to migrate into. OTOH, I use Sublime Text...
Re:Apple's iTunes Is Alienating Its Most Music-Obsessed Users by CamperBob2 on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @11:10AM (#10588495)
And don't forget the innovative iTunes "cloud" icon. Translation: No, you can't listen to this track until it's been downloaded from the "cloud," but fortunately for you, the 3 or 4 identical duplicate tracks in your collection will play just fine.

iTunes is the only good argument I've seen for requiring software engineers to be licensed by the government.

Re:Apple's iTunes Is Alienating Its Most Music-Obsessed Users by happyscrappy on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @12:58PM (#10589464)
Careful what you wish for.
Re:Apple's iTunes Is Alienating Its Most Music-Obsessed Users by CamperBob2 on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @01:51PM (#10589860)
Very true. I couldn't think of a better insult on short notice, so I went with the first one that came to mind.
Re:Apple's iTunes Is Alienating Its Most Music-Obsessed Users by bane on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @12:47PM (#10589353)
> I'm not sure I really understand the people who use alternate music player software on OS X; huge collections of downloaded music files accessed through file player software doesn't seem like where digital music is headed. I had a gigantic collection of purchased music on my computer, and it's more an annoyance now than anything else.

I agree with you, but for those with the wherewithal, dumping all the files into a folder and pointing plex at it gives you a personal "cloud" with great capabilities, cross platform, on-the-web, mobile apps, etc.

Re:Apple's iTunes Is Alienating Its Most Music-Obsessed Users by ryanmonroe on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @11:43AM (#10588824)
Most people who have large collections of music have a lot of files that aren't available on any streaming service. Not sure if the sound quality of these services is on par with 320kbps MP3 files either.
Re:Apple's iTunes Is Alienating Its Most Music-Obsessed Users by Nicolechen on Thursday November 26, 2015 @04:56AM (#10632216)
Maybe there are some ways to convert Apple music to unprotected format and then we can enjoy them on any players as we want. I just learned about Notebunrer recently launches a Apple music converter, I prepare to try this and perhaps buy a license during black friday. I am waiting for a big deal.
Re:Apple's iTunes Is Alienating Its Most Music-Obsessed Users by pfg on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @12:59PM (#10589473)
Apple Music does allow you to stream music that's not available on their platform. iTunes will upload them when first added, and other devices can then stream from Apple.
Re:Apple's iTunes Is Alienating Its Most Music-Obsessed Users by seivan on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @11:13AM (#10588544)
It gained me as a user recently. I never used it until Apple Music and with the recent Apple TV it's pretty much awesome.

(Replaced Spotify)

Though one of Spotify strengths were its API. Apple needs an API so people people can get different front-ends and thus pretty much kill(?) Spotify for those who dislike iTunes.