Politics can be so divisive and get so heated that even people who are interested are afraid to talk about it in public.
I think the problem is that a political party or candidate is a very low-bandwidth symbol that loses most of the information contained in that choice. The fact that a Mormon, a woman, and a black guy are running means that any vote can be interpreted as discrimination against the group not chosen. For example, if you told me you voted for John Edwards, should I assume you like his economic populism or that you're too narrow minded for a black or woman president? If you vote for a Republican, does that mean you are a homophobe? It's like trying to express everything you believe about anything, the moral, ethical, and intellectual debates you have inside into two bits (party, candidate). That's a hard problem.
Maybe somebody should submit an "Ask YC: What Presidential candidate do you like?" That way everybody could get their political opinions off their chest once and for all, and we wouldn't have to suffer through ten months of this kind of stuff.