Certainly the idea that gold is immune to inflation, overvalue or a bubble is entirely absurd and outright dangerous to the people who might fall into the trap of believing it.
[1] If someone had such an algorithm Wall Street financial firms would be making untold amounts of money off of it, most trading algorithms are just rough heuristics that happen to work, but rarely work for extensive periods of time or any specific claims.
The US dollar's value is dropping (and will continue to drop) sharply since they are printing them like mad. If the value of the dollar drops, the value of things relative to the dollar rises (like gold). There isn't a gold bubble, there's a dollar devaluation. The dollar may have been stable in the past, but those days are almost certainly over.
There may be flaws with the CPI-U data, but I don't know of a better data source. Feel free to point one out.
Until you do however, the data we've explored in this thread directly contradicts all of your assertions, despite their popularity among some.
But of course people just love to think about owning gold and that's what's really driving this madness.
Do you not recognize how often people used to say the same thing about US real estate before 2005?
If you want to hedge against inflation then might I suggest US currency? It's remarkably stable and inflates by only a 3-6 points most years: http://www.inflationdata.com/inflation/images/charts/Annual_...