Using a subpoena to threaten scientists for finding results you don't agree with is a form of censorship.
So now what? How do you collect and analyze data when trust in those doing the collection and analysis is not a given?
One approach is to implicitly trust scientists, because they are experts in their field, while you are a novice. This is what a lot of us do, and I think it's a perfectly fine solution, but it is a trade-off; you might misplace your trust.
Another approach is to train up on the science yourself, so that you can independently verify things. This is a great solution, but it isn't scalable. Most people have other jobs and other interests, and in any case, you can never be an expert in everything that matters.
Another approach might be to try to build trust using out-of-band signals, like transparent communication. Transparency often sounds nice, but it also has a major chilling effect, because people communicate more efficiently in the sorts of candid conversations that are hard to have publicly.
Personally, I think the witch hunt for biased climate scientists is disgusting and beside the point, but I also find it distasteful to suggest that it isn't a really hard problem to disseminate trusted information about complex subjects in a highly specialized society.
> The Office of Technology Assessment (OTA) was an office of the United States Congress from 1972 to 1995. OTA's purpose was to provide Congressional members and committees with objective and authoritative analysis of the complex scientific and technical issues of the late 20th century, i.e. technology assessment. It was a leader in practicing and encouraging delivery of public services in innovative and inexpensive ways, including early involvement in the distribution of government documents through electronic publishing. Its model was widely copied around the world.
It was de-funded "Contract with America" period of the 1990s.
Science is global endeavour based on data. If one scientists is lax or fraudulent, there are numerous incentives for competing scientists to prove so.
But in practice, science depends on the trust that scientists aren't actively subverting the process: failing to consider alternate hypothesis, fabricating data, ignoring data, deliberately filtering for confirmatory data, groupthink, etc.
So an import safeguard is the ability to detect when someone is doing the above, even if the detector doesn't know the literature well enough to refute it.
With that said, that doesn't mean there's enough evidence of misconduct to justify a subpoena in this case; I'm just saying, it's not simply a matter of "just look at the data rather than the people".