News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Advertising Bubble by elorant on Monday November 16, 2015 @05:17AM (#10573603)
In my seventeen years online I’ve never ever bought a product or service based on an ad. I’ve bought from newsletters but never from ads. The difference the way I see it is that newsletters are highly targeted because they originate from a web site that I frequently visit. Whilst ads rarely take into account the frequency of your searches. You happen to search for shoes once and then for weeks, or even months, after you’re bombarded with relevant ads.
Re:The Advertising Bubble by eterm on Monday November 16, 2015 @05:20AM (#10573612)
Well that's one anecdote, here's another:

My first ever online purchase was direct from an advert.

I needed 128mb more RAM, so I bought it from crucial. I knew of crucial because a gaming forum I visited had a single banner advert for crucial that never changed, so I always noticed it.

Advertising works, and even if you think it doesn't you're wrong. Every day you'll make purchasing decisions and often you'll tend toward products you recognise the name of. That process doesn't come from magic, it comes from advertising, the majority of which you'll not even notice.

Re:The Advertising Bubble by throwaway800 on Monday November 16, 2015 @05:58AM (#10573743)
My everyday purchasing decisions are mostly driven by opening my cupboard and checking if there is enough muesli left for the next three days. I haven't seen advertising inside my cupboard yet but any day now...
Re:The Advertising Bubble by sharemywin on Monday November 16, 2015 @09:29AM (#10574585)
so you can't name one brand. If so then advertising is working. when you went to go make a purchasing decision if that brand was even considered advertising did it's job.
Re:The Advertising Bubble by throwaway800 on Monday November 16, 2015 @09:58AM (#10574740)
Is this a useful definition of advertising, especially in the context of everyday purchases brought up by eterm? The most prominent brand I interact with is a major grocery chain. This is because they have a huge store 5 minutes from my house. I'm not going to start going to another store even if it carpet-bombs my browser to get brand awareness. VC-funded adtech won't help anyone scale brick and mortar.

My purchasing decisions are based mainly on whatever is the cheapest. I do find brands useful, to the extent that if a product is brand-name, it's likely to be more expensive than the no-name variety one shelf below. Saves some mental effort of comparing prices more closely.

The muesli I purchase is store-brand. I have made the decision by comparing nutritional content of a number of varieties.

I have been advertised to to get me to look at the nutrition labels, I suppose.

Re:The Advertising Bubble by TheLogothete on Monday November 16, 2015 @06:43AM (#10573873)
Your whole life and reality is created by advertising.
Re:The Advertising Bubble by throwaway800 on Monday November 16, 2015 @06:56AM (#10573916)
Well, at least that's what advertising agencies advertise to their clients :)

The best-paying sells advertisers make is to their clients and their industry peers.

Re:The Advertising Bubble by TheLogothete on Monday November 16, 2015 @07:07AM (#10573935)
Extremely vain and naive thinking. Best people to market to :)