News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What is Square or any startup really worth? by loginusername on Monday November 16, 2015 @02:31AM (#10573103)
Must answer question: Worth to whom?

Not every potential buyer will agree on the "worth" of X.

Ultimately X is not worth anything unless and until X is sold.

Perhaps the tense is wrong.

Not what _is_ X worth, but what _will be_ the worth of X (when X is sold).

In the end, "worth" is "price paid" (by some buyer).

Re:What is Square or any startup really worth? by ragnarok451 on Monday November 16, 2015 @03:31AM (#10573268)
That's true, but what I think they generally refer to is the price the market would pay (that is, the price/share where demand for a share will equal the supply).

You are correct that "X is not worth anything unless and until X is sold" - that is why they are saying that IPOs may be lower than expected for these huge valuations - because the equilibrium market price is believed to be lower than the current valuations, priced by a small market of investors. According to the efficient market hypothesis stocks on the stock market will trade at their fair value (that's pretty disputed, but a good amount of respected people agree with it).