News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FastMail: Shutting down our XMPP chat service by colanderman on Monday November 16, 2015 @12:32AM (#10572791)
Doesn't excuse Google, Facebook, WhatsApp, and Apple, from building closed protocols and actively thwarting attempts to make third-party apps.

(Yes, I know they're for-profit companies who have every reason not to want to relinquish any control over their network. Doesn't mean I can't hate on them for not even pretending to support consumer choice.)

Re:FastMail: Shutting down our XMPP chat service by techsupporter on Monday November 16, 2015 @12:42AM (#10572819)
> not even pretending to support consumer choice

By my way of thinking, your choice of language (not because of you, the person, but of how the words have become ingrained) is indicative of the problem: "consumer" versus "customer." We consume what the various companies choose to offer to us in the way they offer it. We are not treated as customers, valued or otherwise, in a competitive landscape. There exists a one-way flow, from the company doing the advertising to our eyeballs to consume it.

Look at the businesses people claim to like: local shops, service providers like Fastmail, and the like. In those cases the people giving them money are treated as customers who have other choices and who have made the voluntary choice to continue to associate with that business.

That's what is missing. Customer instead of consumer.

Re:FastMail: Shutting down our XMPP chat service by troydavis on Monday November 16, 2015 @11:56AM (#10575488)
When someone raises this concern, I ask who hosts their personal email. 30-50% use a legacy free Google Apps account or Gmail. When I ask why, it's a variation on "because FastMail costs ~$40/year."

Of the rest, more than half host their own MX. While that's totally reasonable, it means the percentage of people willing to pay just $3/month to be a customer is even smaller than it seems. And $40/year is the cheapest that one could ever hope "being a customer" would cost.

So, lots of people say they want to be customers, but even when doing so is close to free, very few actually do.

(Nothing wrong with using Google because it's free, only while concurrently claiming to want to be a customer. I agree with your point and I'm a happy FastMail customer. I'm amazed FastMail can make a profit at $40 and it's a huge credit to them that they can.)

Re:FastMail: Shutting down our XMPP chat service by colanderman on Monday November 16, 2015 @12:53AM (#10572862)
I wonder, if we were proper customers of Facebook and paid them to transport our messages, whether it would open the possibility of a Ma Bell-style antitrust lawsuit. Force interconnectivity to allow the little guys to play too.
Re:FastMail: Shutting down our XMPP chat service by prohor on Monday November 16, 2015 @01:04AM (#10572886)
WhatsApp is paid (after a year), but it doesn't help with supporting any open IM standard.
Re:FastMail: Shutting down our XMPP chat service by aerique on Monday November 16, 2015 @05:35AM (#10573664)
Yeah, I've never understood this. I've seen it now-and-then when installing WA for family members, but I (and they) have never, ever had to pay for it after using it for multiple years.
Re:FastMail: Shutting down our XMPP chat service by feld on Monday November 16, 2015 @07:10AM (#10573946)
It's free since Facebook bought them. I've had Android friends mention payment screens are still on their WhatsApp though.
Re:FastMail: Shutting down our XMPP chat service by marcosdumay on Monday November 16, 2015 @09:48AM (#10574685)
It was free before Facebook brought them too. It just nagged people to pay once a year, but if one didn't pay, it just kept working.
Re:FastMail: Shutting down our XMPP chat service by _cudgel on Monday November 16, 2015 @03:25AM (#10573244)
s/Customer/Citizen/ and you've hit on a large portion of the problem with representative democracy.
Re:FastMail: Shutting down our XMPP chat service by Camillo on Monday November 16, 2015 @01:14AM (#10572916)
What about Comcast? What about airlines?