News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:State of emergency in France by DanBC on Saturday November 14, 2015 @11:28AM (#10566159)
> No, there's only one ideology on the planet with a radicalized extreme minority that supports and promotes this kind of behavior.

The Buddhists? They have at least one army and two terrorist groups.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/969_Movement

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_Karen_Buddhist_Army

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bodu_Bala_Sena

Or perhaps the Sikhs? There are still some active Sikh terrorist groups. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khalistan_movement#Abatement_o...

And before you say that those groups don't affect America: http://www.nbcnews.com/news/other/nevada-man-charged-aiding-...

Perhaps you mean Christians? There are a bunch, such as the Lord's Resistance Army (now operating in Sudan) as well as a bunch who have carried out actions in mainland US. In the US the main threat is from either Christian or right wing extremist groups.

Re:State of emergency in France by api on Saturday November 14, 2015 @01:06PM (#10566568)
Any belief system theistic or not can become fanatical and violent as soon as it's followers become obsessed and decide that the end justifies the means. The 20th century saw quite a few atheistic or at least non religious political ideologies behaving no better than this.

Radical Islam today seems to be doing all the same things that radical fascists and Marxists did in the 20th century.

Re:State of emergency in France by DanBC on Saturday November 14, 2015 @01:08PM (#10566578)
> Radical Islam

But there are plenty of other radical groups. Today the right wing extremists are a greater threat to Americans than Muslims are.

Re:State of emergency in France by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 14, 2015 @01:16PM (#10566600)
And radical drivers are a greater threat to Europeans than Muslims are, since they do "become obsessed" (with the right to drive like they like regardless what the law says) and "decide that the end" (getting to the red light 2 seconds faster) "justifies the means" (speeding), killing a lot more of people in the process than terror attacks ever did.

The point is, there are many other groups we could focus on and be much more productive with it. Hell, "radical Islam" probaly has the feature that if we elected to ignore it instead of messing with it abroad and radicalizing people even further, it'd probably eventually go away.

But either way, it's a job for the police to deal with, and it does not call for the general population to start retaliating on innocent people who sorta, kinda look a little similar to the radical branch of a radical branch of a foreign religion.

Re:State of emergency in France by api on Saturday November 14, 2015 @01:26PM (#10566639)
Is this really true? I don't argue that home grown fanatics are not a threat, but I don't see a current organized systemic effort from them to do much of anything other than squawk on the net.

The lone nut shooter epidemic is something else. It's not ideological. Seems to be more of a mental health issue.

Re:State of emergency in France by DanBC on Saturday November 14, 2015 @02:34PM (#10566896)
Your stigmatising language around mental illness means I'm unable to answer this question and stay within HN rules. Just remember that many of those people didn't have signs of mental illness and were not known to MH services; and that people with mental illness are more likely to be the victims of violence than the perpetrators of violence.

But the US has had doctors killed and medical clinics bombed by Christian groups. Anti-abortionist protesters try to deny women their reproductive rights and regularly threaten doctors and nurses and admin staff at medical clinics. (This is a war crime if a state does it.)

Here's what the FBI said in 2002: https://www.fbi.gov/news/testimony/the-terrorist-threat-conf...

> At the same time, the United States also faces significant challenges from domestic terrorists. In fact, between 1980 and 2000, the FBI recorded 335 incidents or suspected incidents of terrorism in this country. Of these, 247 were attributed to domestic terrorists, while 88 were determined to be international in nature.

Re:State of emergency in France by rebootthesystem on Saturday November 14, 2015 @11:19PM (#10568471)
Oh, please. Airports have turned to shit because of the groups you quoted. Right? And the beheadings, that's those crazy Buddhists right? No, it's the NRA guys with their ridiculous guns. Yeah, it's them. Dammit.

Please. Let's get real. We know the elephant in the room. It's not "Mother Theresa Gone Wild".

You and everyone else fully understand the problem. Let's stop pretending it's something else.

Re:State of emergency in France by TeMPOraL on Sunday November 15, 2015 @03:03AM (#10568888)
Airports turned to shit because of a particular group of people - namely, politicians of the United States of America. This is an example of totally uncalled for overreaction that by itself probably did more economic damage than all the terrorist attacks in the US combined.
Re:State of emergency in France by rebootthesystem on Sunday November 15, 2015 @01:09PM (#10570407)
How would you propose to protect the millions of passengers who fly every day from terrorists?

I am not challenging you. I simply want to know what you are thinking because it sounds like you may have thought this through to some depth. You obviously think politicians made the wrong decision (which isn't hard to believe) and might have a better solution than the crap we've had to deal with since 9/11.

What alternatives did these politicians have and ignored? What else could they have done?

I don't think anyone, including myself, likes what air travel has become. Yet, I am not sure I could have come up with a better solution. If terrorism disappeared for ten years perhaps we could go back to the kind of hassle free experience air travel used to be.

What's your idea?

Re:State of emergency in France by TeMPOraL on Monday November 16, 2015 @12:04AM (#10572704)
> What alternatives did these politicians have and ignored? What else could they have done?

They've ignored the most important alternative that is unfortunately often forgotten or seen as weeknes - that you can also do nothing. Or at least do only things that make some sense.

Airports aren't really more secure than they were before 9/11. I'd argue they're even less secure against terrorist attack, because if you wanted to maximize the damage to people, you just go and bomb the security line. You've got hundreds of people tightly packed in a closed space there.

The reality is, terrorism (or generally, politically-motivated murder of civilians) simply doesn't happen often enough that we should care. It's also by definition pretty much completely unpredictable, because the attacker has freedom to pick their target and spend as much time on preparations as they want. Arm the population? Terrorists will use remote-detonated bombs or suicide vests. Turn all airports into high-security facilities? Terrorists will attack at security checkpoints, or just switch to bombing buses instead. If they wanted, they'd murdered us by the thousands already. The reason it doesn't happen is that humans generally just don't go blowing themselves up and/or killing random people.

Also, keep in mind that causalties in terror attacks are only collateral damage, and not the goal. The reason for such attacks is to push the harmed society into the state of panic, at which point they'll start overreacting and doing stupid things to themselves and others.

So in the hypothetical more rational world, what could have politicians done?

- Leave the airports be vs. starting the security theatre industry. Not to say all air travel security is bad; pilot cabin doors are an improvement, though after that last catastrophe in Europe you could say it's an double-edged... shield.

- Don't start two wars vs. starting two wars. This definitely made more terrorists, not to mention it killed about three orders of magnitude more innocent people than 9/11 itself.

- Don't terrorize Pakistan vs. drone-strinking the living shit out of civilians there. This definitely created more potential terrorists.

- Shut the fuck up about it in media. Ok, so the towers fell, it's a tragedy. We should mourn the dead, clean up the mess, redirect funds to investigate and bring to justice people responsible, but otherwise there's nothing to see here.

- Redirect the saved money to other programs. 'gnaritas posted a helpful CDC "top 10 causes of death in the US" list. Any money spent towards fixing any of the items on this list is much better spent than directing it towards "war on terror".

Re:State of emergency in France by rebootthesystem on Monday November 16, 2015 @01:39AM (#10572987)
Nonsense. If we didn't have greater security for air travel aircraft would rain from the skies. And the sheer devastation to global economies would have no imaginable measure. Is security perfect? Far from it. But it is far better than doing nothing.

I think you might be blind to a whole layer of the infrastructure because you never have visibility into it. I do. I own a company that conducts business internationally. Passenger aircraft don't just carry passengers. Before the extensive security measures implemented progressively after 9-11 taking down a plane with cargo would have almost been child's play. Today, not so. I don't know how much you travel. If you do, be thankful there are people who did their best to ensure someone isn't shipping an incendiary device on the same plane you and your family happen to be on.

The business of attempting to create equivalency between deaths due to smoking or heat disease and terrorism is simply laughable at best. There is no equivalence and nothing prevents anyone from addressing them as the separate and unrelated problems they are.

Re:State of emergency in France by TeMPOraL on Monday November 16, 2015 @02:36AM (#10573115)
> If we didn't have greater security for air travel aircraft would rain from the skies.

Did something changed fundamentally about human condition after 9/11? Planes didn't generally get attacked before, and they didn't generally get attacked after. There were a few incidents on both sides of 9/11. I don't see any reason to attribute things going as they always have been to security theatre erected around the 9/11 events.

> I think you might be blind to a whole layer of the infrastructure because you never have visibility into it.

I might be. Please share some details then, I'm always eager to learn something new and reevaluate my opinions.

> Today, not so. I don't know how much you travel. If you do, be thankful there are people who did their best to ensure someone isn't shipping an incendiary device on the same plane you and your family happen to be on.

I do travel enough, mostly on business. I am very thankful to all people ensuring my safety in air and on the ground. But I do question a lot of the efforts that were introduced as a reaction to events of 9/11.

Re:State of emergency in France by rebootthesystem on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @01:48AM (#10579544)
Well, I'll just say there are at least two kinds of people in this world, those who tend to see things for what they are (not 100% of the time but often enough) and those we need reality to really hit them hard before they finally understand.

I see a lot of people on HN, you and @gnaritas included, living in that second camp. Refusing to see reality for what it is and insisting the emperor has beautiful clothes. I imagine you and @gnaritas as people who would dismiss all the mounting evidence as the Nazi's prepared to kill millions of Jews, including openly stating they were going to perfect the techniques used by the Turks to kill a couple million Armenians during the first world war.

Report after report came out of these regions for both Genocides. Images, telegraphs all all sorts of evidence of what was coming and what was happening. There were those who screamed bloody murder and saw the mounting evidence for what it was: A path to genocide. And, of course, there were those who said shit like "Oh, never mind the Armenians" or "Never mind the Jews", "more people die in car accidents every year, what they hell are you people crying about". And millions died.

I am not going to continue going back and forth with people who refuse to see reality for what it is. We --the World-- are not headed for a good place. We could be headed for something truly horrific.

Creating equivalence with car accidents and cancer and arguing from a position of insanely ridiculous minutiae in the face of attacks, threats videos, beheading, suicide bombers, mass killings and the terrorists themselves getting on the internet and social media to tell all of us EXACTLY what their intentions ares. Well, my friend, this is just insisting to be blind to a reality that is out there in plain sight for all to see.

I fear people like you simply refuse to understand even after six million people perish in a Genocide. I would love to be able to interview some of the people who dismissed the mounting evidence for the first and second genocides of the 20th century. I wonder what the people who ignored the images and telegraphs thought of themselves years later as they realized what happened and how they refused to accept reality.

So, that's it. I don't know where this is headed but it looks worst with ever turn. I hope world leaders take action and stop this snowball from hell from leading us in a direction none of us wants to even consider. I am not going to argue with you any more because we obviously don't see eye to eye.

I truly hope you never get the evidence you need to convince you that you are being blind and you are looking at this the wrong way. And I say that sincerely because that day will not be a good day for humanity.