News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:State of emergency in France by scrollaway on Saturday November 14, 2015 @10:16AM (#10565911)
You're asking for more ideas and this is something I've had to painstakingly talk to people about all day, so here's a shot at this.

First of all, identify the problem. Why are there terrorist attacks? Saying "religious nuttery" achieves nothing. Nuttery always exists but is in majority not enough to push people to suicide bombings. Terrorist attacks exist because of political power and influence. They're efficient, because we let them be efficient.

Compare it to the drug trade. [Cartels|terrorist cults] thrive because there is [money|power] to be made. Going after the [cartels|terrorists] is not enough long term. [Jailing|Discriminating against] [potheads|muslims] only serves to worsen the situation for them, pushing them even further out of society, but does nothing to solve the problem. Criminalizing the components such as [drugs|encryption] only makes the problem worse for your citizens, doesn't affect the bad guys. You need to take care of the problem at the root by removing the bad guys' incentives.

In the case of terrorist cults, religion is a mask. It's just whatever's currently marginalizing people as much as possible. You see, marginalized people make for excellent subjects. Just like any other cult, they prey on the weak. They prey on the ones who are feeling alone, those feeling rejected by everybody even their own country. Those who have nowhere else to go find a place they're taken care of, where they're cheaply promised great rewards (in the afterlife) and where they can find a purpose. Not just that, but somewhere they can take revenge on the country that hates them.

"Muslim" terrorists know quite well that their attacks only make the lives of muslims worse. They only serve to get them more subjects so they can get even more political power.

So you want an idea? You take care of that problem. You start teaching others about how those cults really work - know your enemy. You make people understand that more hatred, more blood, are exactly what the terrorists want. That's why we call them terrorists: Politics through terror. Education. Teaching to be more critical of media - media has complete control over the narrative through most mediums, and as long as some media outlets stand to gain from instilling fear of your neighbour, they'll keep doing it and readers will not be any less impressionable for it.

I dunno, maybe it'll make a difference. Maybe it won't. I want to believe it will, but today, as a French person, I have seen more xenophobia than I care to admit. I'm hating humanity pretty badly right now. HN has been the only place where I've found mostly reasonable reactions.

Re:State of emergency in France by vlehto on Saturday November 14, 2015 @10:31AM (#10565958)
It's completely possible that the message sent here was not aimed to anybody living in France.

It's also likely that certain large portion of French are not going to be satisfied unless something drastic is done. To them it's not about the problem, it is about feelings and identity.

So this can't be solved entirely. Best thing to mitigate the problem would be a knee-jerk reaction that does least amount of damage. Because in democracy you will have that knee-jerk, sooner or later.

Re:State of emergency in France by scrollaway on Saturday November 14, 2015 @10:38AM (#10565975)
> Best thing to mitigate the problem would be a knee-jerk reaction that does least amount of damage. Because in democracy you will have that knee-jerk, sooner or later.

That's an interesting take on it, and I don't really disagree with it. Maybe I hate that I don't disagree with it though. I hate having to settle for something. :/

Re:State of emergency in France by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 14, 2015 @10:42AM (#10565991)
I hate it too :/. But it makes sense. A valve to relieve pressure - in some direction that isn't destructive, or doesn't contribute to further radicalization, creating a feedback loop.
Re:State of emergency in France by vlehto on Saturday November 14, 2015 @11:42AM (#10566229)
I'd like to be wrong on this one too.

Functional democracy is as intelligent as average voter is. Hopefully education can make the world better place. But it's going to take a long time to do it.

Re:State of emergency in France by mercurial on Saturday November 14, 2015 @11:14AM (#10566107)
> It's completely possible that the message sent here was not aimed to anybody living in France.

Why? France is bombing ISIS in Syria. That's also what the attackers were saying.

Re:State of emergency in France by vlehto on Saturday November 14, 2015 @11:40AM (#10566212)
If the attackers are saying that, their real message is probably "Look, the French are not safe. We are capable of revenge." to other ISIS fighters in Syria. Morale of your own troops is of paramount importance in a war.

I think France, or any nation for that matter has very poor track record of backing down military operations after terrorist attack.

Re:State of emergency in France by return0 on Saturday November 14, 2015 @11:07AM (#10566075)
Except these don't appear to be a political terrorist group, like the ones we have in Europe. This is jihad, blind violence, without targeting political figures. If you ask the bombers why they do it they 'll barely be able to answer beyond some religious nonsense. If you ask the ones who sent them to bomb, i bet you will find a mixture of vague anti-westernism , anti-semitism etc. Whoever is funding them does not have a world-changing plan other than general disorder. Even if ISIS had a UN-recognized state, they wouldn't be able to keep it functioning for a single day.

It's easy to be a terrorist nowadays, because it's hard to come up with solutions to fix the broken arab world. It probably doesn't take huge funding to do the things they do. Is there a viable political agenda behind them? If there was, arabs wouldn't be fleeing the area in droves.

Re:State of emergency in France by Shorel on Saturday November 14, 2015 @12:12PM (#10566361)
> blind violence

It is in my own not politically correct opinion (I expect to be downvoted for this) not blind at all. It is targeted against freedom of expression and also against feminism, which they see as immoral. It is targeted towards freedom of expression because of the dogmas regarding the depiction of their own religious figures, and that is intimately related to their religion. And all that happens because they went to other countries, but entirely rejecting other cultures, and their own culture includes trying to convert the entire world to Islam.

This is also a consequence of the Mongols and the Sack of Baghdad in 1258. Before this, Islam was the enlightened culture that preserved Greek discoveries and it was truly the religion of peace. After it, they became much more orthodox and rejected the science they helped preserve.

Re:State of emergency in France by scrollaway on Saturday November 14, 2015 @12:21PM (#10566400)
It truly saddens me every time I write several paragraphs trying to get across the point about islam being used as a tool by people who couldn't give a shit about the religion. Neither on the attacker's side nor on the defending governments' sides.

Am I just not getting my point across?

Re:State of emergency in France by Shorel on Saturday November 14, 2015 @12:34PM (#10566463)
Of course you do. But I think we agree to disagree. I see religions as fundamentally harmful and you don't.
Re:State of emergency in France by scrollaway on Saturday November 14, 2015 @12:46PM (#10566504)
I have not stated what I think of religions anywhere in my posts, because it is not relevant - and I'd wager you would be surprised about my answer should you ask.

What you do see is this being a religious attack, when it is quite clearly a political one. I'm honestly not sure anymore how someone who thinks through the mentality these people have can come to the conclusion that the logic makes sense.

It's just so easy for people to just say "Pah, there's no logic, these people are irrational and crazy and they hate us". But that's bullshit. Everybody is driven by their own set of logic and in the majority of cases, they're easily manipulated by those that are more experienced or stand to gain more than them. This is a fact we have to face: There are horrors being done, and there are reasons behind the horrors being done.

So please, I won't try to convince you - instead, think this through yourself:

  1. Do these attacks serve a religious goal? If so, which?
  2. What are the social consequences on islam and muslims as a result of such attacks?
     Are they predictable? Are they known by the perpetrators?
  3. What happens as a result of those consequences? Who is affected?
     Who is most negatively affected?
  4. Based on your answers on 2 & 3, can you tell who stands to gain the most out of it?
  5. Does your answer to 1 still make sense in the context of your answers to 2, 3 & 4?
Have fun, I'm going to sleep.
Re:State of emergency in France by scrollaway on Saturday November 14, 2015 @11:15AM (#10566118)
Please cite your sources. I appreciate what you're trying to say, but I've been dealing with this for the past 19 hours and you're putting words in the mouths of attackers who are dead or have not been caught.

> Even if ISIS had a UN-recognized state, they wouldn't be able to keep it functioning for a single day.

Do you know why we say "know your enemy"? Because the worst thing you can do when facing a threat is underestimate it. You don't want to be caught off-guard. Statistically if you read this site you are familiar with computer security. Think, how does downplaying and underestimating threats work out, in the itsec world?

> It's easy to be a terrorist nowadays, because it's hard to come up with solutions to fix the broken arab world.

These are two very faintly related points. They're certainly not cause & consequence.

Re:State of emergency in France by codedokode on Saturday November 14, 2015 @01:35PM (#10566666)
> This is jihad, blind violence

This might be a war operation. It is very effective to sacrifice eight soldiers to make the whole army retreat. And other countries might be scared too and withdraw their troops.

> If you ask the ones who sent them to bomb, i bet you will find a mixture of vague anti-westernism , anti-semitism etc.

France is in a war against IS. So they fight with their enemy.

> it's hard to come up with solutions to fix the broken arab world

What about restraining from using force? Using diplomatic and economic measures?