News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DARPA: U.S. Geek Shortage Is National Security Risk by nostrademons on Saturday January 16, 2010 @01:00AM (#1056580)
I've heard the distinction as "software engineering is a creative profession, requiring professionals to exercise a large degree of judgment in building working systems from ambiguous requirements. Programmers take an existing spec and then translate that into code."

I'm not sure how useful this distinction is, as every job I've held had highly ambiguous requirements and a lot of trade-offs involved in building a working system from them. It kinda makes me wonder though - a colleague who'd been a PM at both Google and Microsoft said the difference was "Microsoft expects PMs to produce a spec that's thrown over the wall to engineers, who throw it back if there's any ambiguity. Google expects their engineers to have opinions about the product and to resolve most of the details themselves, only consulting the PM if there's something big where they need additional data." I wonder if Microsoft hires programmers and Google hires software engineers?

Re:DARPA: U.S. Geek Shortage Is National Security Risk by robryan on Saturday January 16, 2010 @02:33AM (#1056649)
I've always hated this attempted separating of the roles of programmer and software engineer. You are taking people best suited to programming and giving them the job of creating a specification which is then given to lower paid code monkeys proficient in Java to churn it out.

I'd kind of cheapens the craft when people look at it in this way, my AI lecturer last year was describing the different roles in creating an AI system and saying that that the job you want is a knowledge engineer is the position you want and the programmer is just a nobody who translates it all into code.

Re:DARPA: U.S. Geek Shortage Is National Security Risk by nostrademons on Saturday January 16, 2010 @02:47AM (#1056654)
I think that you don't often find both software engineers and programmers in the same organization, if that organization subscribes to this distinction. Either you have only software engineers, or you have programmers + software architects.
Re:DARPA: U.S. Geek Shortage Is National Security Risk by pasbesoin on Saturday January 16, 2010 @01:08PM (#1057216)
It also introduces a lot of "friction" and inefficiency into the development process, at least in my experience.
Re:DARPA: U.S. Geek Shortage Is National Security Risk by iigs on Saturday January 16, 2010 @01:14AM (#1056594)
I wonder if Microsoft hires programmers and Google hires software engineers?

I don't think that's a fair assessment of the developers themselves. I would write it up to differences in product release mentality -- it takes a different mindset to put bits in a box vs a web server.

Re:DARPA: U.S. Geek Shortage Is National Security Risk by dangrossman on Saturday January 16, 2010 @06:08AM (#1056788)
Microsoft calls them "Software Development Engineers".