Re:Charity claims it owns “Happy Birthday” song’s copyright
by raving-richard on Saturday November 14, 2015 @08:58PM
(#10568185)
Please note: "Happy Birthday" is well out of copyright in a number of countries that aren't the USA. Including Australia, and any other country that applied the rule that copyright expired 50 years after the death of the author. According to Wikipedia, the copyright expires in the EU at the end of next year (70 years after the death of the last author).
The fact that copyright extends for so long is a travesty and is something that we all should be fighting against (along with all the myriad of other injustices around...).
Re:Charity claims it owns “Happy Birthday” song’s copyright
by jimrandomh on Saturday November 14, 2015 @06:40PM
(#10567803)
This case is sufficiently absurd that its very existence hurts the credibility of the courts. They're allowing peoples' right to sing "Happy Birthday" to depend on the details of a sale that took place in 1893.
Re:Charity claims it owns “Happy Birthday” song’s copyright
by Natsu on Saturday November 14, 2015 @06:20PM
(#10567732)
Actually they sort of do: people make derivative works or compilations that become encumbered when something out of copyright is found to be in copyright again. Something which has happened thanks to nonsense like "common law" state copyrights and retroactive extensions.
Of course, that's an argument against the practice rather than for it.
Re:Charity claims it owns “Happy Birthday” song’s copyright
by NameNickHN on Saturday November 14, 2015 @05:29PM
(#10567560)
It looks like this will be the norm in a couple of years. I expect that there will be a time when no music or books are entering the public domain anymore.
Re:Charity claims it owns “Happy Birthday” song’s copyright
by angelbob on Saturday November 14, 2015 @05:46PM
(#10567610)
We're basically there already. Disney pushes back the copyright date every decade or two so that Mickey Mouse (steamboat willy, 1920s) never gets into the public domain.
Re:Charity claims it owns “Happy Birthday” song’s copyright
by mtgx on Saturday November 14, 2015 @06:25PM
(#10567758)
Well you know, if the author's grand-grandchildren don't live off his work, it might make him not want to create anymore...
Or it could be just that the corporations which bought many of the money-making copyrights long ago want to continue to receive royalties from it indefinitely.
Re:Charity claims it owns “Happy Birthday” song’s copyright
by scoot on Saturday November 14, 2015 @06:42PM
(#10567806)
A tangential question - if ownership is established, would said owner have a case against Warner for the $2M a year they've been raking in against an illegitimate copyright claim?
Re:Charity claims it owns “Happy Birthday” song’s copyright
by jcranmer on Saturday November 14, 2015 @07:52PM
(#10568000)
The timing basis for copyright starts counting down at the date of first authorized publication, not at the state of conception. Well, pre-1976; the 1976 copyright act actually starts the clock from the date of fixation.
The essential problem with the Happy Birthday song is that no one is quite sure who created it, and thus no one is quite sure which publication (if any!) would be an actual authorized publication. It thus falls under really, really gray areas of the law.
It should be noted, however, that the most plausible scenario that could win a victory at court (in terms of being able to prove that copyright exists) would have the copyright expire in about 400 days anyways.
Re:Charity claims it owns “Happy Birthday” song’s copyright
by nathancahill on Saturday November 14, 2015 @11:24PM
(#10568486)
Except collecting donations for charity:water actually goes to bring water to developing countries instead of the pockets of billionaires. Minor difference.
The fact that copyright extends for so long is a travesty and is something that we all should be fighting against (along with all the myriad of other injustices around...).
Of course, that's an argument against the practice rather than for it.
Or it could be just that the corporations which bought many of the money-making copyrights long ago want to continue to receive royalties from it indefinitely.
The essential problem with the Happy Birthday song is that no one is quite sure who created it, and thus no one is quite sure which publication (if any!) would be an actual authorized publication. It thus falls under really, really gray areas of the law.
It should be noted, however, that the most plausible scenario that could win a victory at court (in terms of being able to prove that copyright exists) would have the copyright expire in about 400 days anyways.
Have a party, sing the song, everyone present donates $1 to charity for the "licensing rights".
I haven't done the math, but I'm sure it's not an insignificant amount of money.
Charity: water has a program similar to this.