News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by stray on Friday November 13, 2015 @07:20PM (#10563521)
It is impossible to prevent while only criminals/terrorists have the weapons.

An armed citizenry is not so easily victimized.

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by miguelrochefort on Friday November 13, 2015 @10:06PM (#10564237)
A recent tweet by Newt Gingrich echoes precisely that:

https://twitter.com/newtgingrich/status/665312487147896832

I understand that this is not the popular opinion around here, but I genuinely can't think of an alternative.

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by sirrocco on Friday November 13, 2015 @11:07PM (#10564402)
I call bullshit on that. Tell me one theater/school/whatever attack in the States that has been foiled by armed citizens.
Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by stray on Saturday November 14, 2015 @11:00AM (#10566045)
According to the FBI (https://leb.fbi.gov/2014/january/active-shooter-events-from-...):

[In] 33 percent (17) of the cases that ended before the police arrived, the potential victims at the scene stopped the shooter themselves. Most commonly they physically subdued the attacker (14 cases), but 3 cases involved people at the scene shooting the perpetrator to end the attack.

So it appears that even the FBI says there were 3 over a span of 12 years that were foiled by armed citizens. And that fully one third of them were stopped by citizens without guns.

I would assume that if everybody were armed then, that more than 33 percent would be foiled by armed citizens.

That is of course, if you accept the Federal Bureau of Investigation to be a credible source

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by hyperliner on Friday November 13, 2015 @11:54PM (#10564518)
Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by brogrammer90 on Friday November 13, 2015 @11:55PM (#10564520)
Concealed carry permit holders actually follow the law and don't solicit businesses that are "gun free zones."
Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by miguelrochefort on Saturday November 14, 2015 @12:35PM (#10566464)
"Since 2009, 92 Percent of Mass Shootings Have Occurred in Gun-Free Zones"

http://freedomoutpost.com/2015/10/since-2009-92-percent-of-m...

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by hokkos on Saturday November 14, 2015 @04:31PM (#10567356)
But what is the proportion of not gun free colleges ? (because this is where most shooting are)
Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by kohanz on Friday November 13, 2015 @11:07PM (#10564405)
Whether you agree with him or not, you have to admit that the timing of that politically-charged tweet was in incredibly poor taste.
Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by stray on Saturday November 14, 2015 @11:13AM (#10566104)
Fully disagree.

It is precisely during tragic times like these that people need to be reminded that an unarmed citizenry is completely vulnerable to armed criminals/terrorists.

Gun control has zero effect on people who don't care about the law.

And many innocent people have just died as a result. Hundreds of families have just been forever changed because of it.

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by staunch on Saturday November 14, 2015 @02:35PM (#10566897)
"Now is the time" = I agree with the argument.

"Now is not the time" = I disagree with the argument.

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by miguelrochefort on Saturday November 14, 2015 @12:36PM (#10566476)
I can't think of a better opportunity to post such a tweet.
Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by notahacker on Sunday November 15, 2015 @08:33AM (#10569559)
When your adversaries are armed with suicide bombs and have no intention of living, armed citizens are very easily victimised. Iraqi civilians have plenty of firearms, and minimal restrictions on carrying them.

What actually did reduce the magnitude of the damage caused in the Paris attacks was the kind of intrusive security checks on people entering the Stade de France that are usually rather less popular around here...

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by asadlionpk on Saturday November 14, 2015 @02:13AM (#10564823)
Even if we don't count the side-effects of this. I don't think armed citizens stand a chance against highly trained militants with heavy weaponry.
Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by stray on Saturday November 14, 2015 @11:03AM (#10566058)
Have any idea how many of us are even better trained ex-military?

In the US, about 13.4% of men are veterans. And 1.4% of women are veterans. So if you're in a theater with a hundred men and a hundred women -- fifteen of those people are competent in the responsible use if firearms AND have proven themselves willing to put their lives on the line for their countrymen.

I'd put money on an overweight, half-blind, ARMED, 60 year old US Marine up against 5 religious zealots with AK-47s any day of the week.

Hell, even those Air Force guys probably know what they're doing :-)

[dead]
Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by stone-monkey on Saturday November 14, 2015 @04:51AM (#10565124)
There's really no way to know for sure what would have happened in this situation if other citizens had guns, but it's possible they could have limited some casualties. However, looser gun laws aren't such a simple issue. If you're considering the societal impact of gun proliferation, you have to weigh the pros and the cons.

While there may be more people available to stop gunmen because of the access to guns, increased access to firearms increases the number of firearm related accidents. This is really something that comes with the territory. No matter how much gun safety is taught, there's always going to be a distribution of people who fall outside of safe usage of guns. At that point, you have to consider whether, as a nation, does the number of casualties based on this incident outweigh the potential number of casualties based on firearm related incidents caused by increased proliferation of guns?

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by yongjik on Friday November 13, 2015 @11:57PM (#10564525)
From Wikipedia:

> According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, in 2013, firearms (excluding BB and pellet guns) were used in 84,258 nonfatal injuries (26.65 per 100,000 U.S. citizens) [2] and 11,208 deaths by homicide (3.5 per 100,000),[3] 21,175 by suicide with a firearm,[4] 505 deaths due to accidental discharge of a firearm,[4] and 281 deaths due to firearms-use with "undetermined intent"[5] for a total of 33,169 deaths related to firearms (excluding firearm deaths due to legal intervention).

So, 11,713 homicides and accidents in the US, not counting suicide. This week alone, gun will likely kill more Americans than the attack on Paris today.

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by stray on Saturday November 14, 2015 @11:31AM (#10566176)
By that reasoning it is three times more important to prevent automobile ownership, three times more important to prevent access to poisonous substances, and three times more important to prevent high places.

Because the three most common causes of accidental death in the US are Unintentional fall deaths, Motor vehicle traffic deaths, and Unintentional poisoning deaths. And each of those kills roughly three times as many Americans as guns.

When you add in intentional firearm deaths, it's roughly the same as automobile deaths -- yet we give 16 year olds the keys without a second thought.

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by yongjik on Saturday November 14, 2015 @01:34PM (#10566662)
Of course it is more important to prevent automobile ownership. That's why the US has DMV offices, administrating automobile ownership and zealously preventing "unqualified" people from driving these vehicles. Imagine how many more will die if people say "Driving a vehicle isn't privilege, it's my basic right."

Snark aside, I think we're talking about different problems. The comment I'm replying to proposed that arming citizens will solve (or mitigate) the problem of terrorism. I pointed out that the proposed solution will kill orders of magnitude more people than terrorism itself. Automobiles are a separate problem.

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by stray on Saturday November 14, 2015 @03:13PM (#10567038)
Yeah I just think the increased number of accidental shootings will balance or possibly exceed the number if intentional shootings including terrorism.

A guy with a gun isn't going to be as brave when he knows others probably have guns too. And most shootings are intentional.

So it seems no more dangerous to arm everybody. And possibly far less dangerous. Not to mention that many other types of crime would likely decrease as well.

You know, because of the threat of getting shoy by your would-be victim.

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by j2bax on Sunday November 15, 2015 @01:19PM (#10570446)
That's debatable. I have to think of situations like one I saw in the news recently where some hero decided he should shoot an unarmed robber in the mall. I think there would be far more situations like this if everyone was packing. People aren't always very rational and if every time a major conflict breaks out the guns come out you are going to have a far bigger issue than the occasional terrorist attack. I'm not saying I don't agree that well trained individuals shouldn't be able to carry and provide safety to everyone around them, but I don't think the grand majority of the populous would be willing to put in the time to have this kind of training. Even if everyone has a gun, handling a terrorist in a crowded space can be a very tricky ordeal and you could easily have people killing each other with crossfire if everyone is trying to take them out.
Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by tvm on Saturday November 14, 2015 @04:47AM (#10565115)
This can be somewhat misleading.

eg.,:

http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2012/jul/22/gun-hom...

Brazil, Italy etc. - significantly lower percentage of firearms between citizens (say compared to USA), yet there are percentually more homicides performed with firearm.

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by disabledalpha on Saturday November 14, 2015 @06:33AM (#10565327)
One has to be careful there. Yes, according to that data, in Italy 67% of homicides are by firearm while 11.9% of people have a firearm. Since the numbers for the US are 60% and 89% one is tempted to conclude that in Italy there are more firearm related homicides. However, this is false. If one looks at the fourth column it is clear that in Italy there are 0.71 homicides by firearm for each 100k peoples while in the US there are 2.97, more than 4 times as many.

Brasil on the other hand has indeed much more homicides per 100k people than the US, although having only an 8% of the population legally possessing a weapon.

TL;DR: In Italy there are four times less homicides by firearm per 100k people than in the US.

Re:Ask HN: What can we do against terrorist attacks, like th... by 6d0debc071 on Saturday November 14, 2015 @05:30AM (#10565219)
And the body counts in the school shootings, would they also be less than ten?