News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by pavel_lishin on Friday January 15, 2010 @05:03PM (#1055996)
The decree was also condemned by Articolo 21, an organization dedicated to the defense of freedom of speech as enshrined in article 21 of the Italian constitution.

So what are the first 20 dedicated to?

Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by ugh on Friday January 15, 2010 @05:20PM (#1056038)
Fundamental principles, other rights: http://www.senato.it/documenti/repository/istituzione/costit... [pdf]

The freedom of speech article is the ninth of the rights. A bit late as constitutions go (USA: first, Germany: fifth) but pretty consistent with many Europeans’ views on freedom of speech. In many European states free speech is not the same sort of fundamental right as it is in the US. Important, sure, but not quite as.

Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by eru on Friday January 15, 2010 @06:03PM (#1056126)
> The freedom of speech article is the ninth of the rights. A bit late as constitutions go (USA: first, Germany: fifth) but pretty consistent with many Europeans’ views on freedom of speech. In many European states free speech is not the same sort of fundamental right as it is in the US. Important, sure, but not quite as.

In defense of Germany: In the US rights come as amendments. The German constitution starts out with the human (and civil) rights at the very beginning. (Yes, someone wanted to distance themself from the Nazis.)

Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by fleitz on Friday January 15, 2010 @07:18PM (#1056243)
If you want to get technical about the US constitution the constitution merely enumerates SOME of the rights that exist, it certainly does not grant them, the ones listed are simply not disputed (what the right entails certainly is). The US constitution should really be viewed more as enumerating the rights of the government, as all rights not explicitly granted FROM the people TO the US gov't vest with the states or the people.

The Federal Gov't actually gets most of it's power in legal theory from a serious abuse of the interstate commerce clause.

You'll notice that the US constitution doesn't actually grant a right of free speech, it prevents congress making laws abridging the freedom.

Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by ugh on Friday January 15, 2010 @07:37PM (#1056261)
Well. Yes it does. Sure it does.

You may not share that opinion, but the way the court sees it counts, not the way you see it. A constitution is more than a piece of paper.

Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by eru on Saturday January 16, 2010 @02:03PM (#1057300)
Please pardon my double-post. The mobile broadband dongle gives a very spotty connection.
Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by eru on Friday January 15, 2010 @05:59PM (#1056121)
> The freedom of speech article is the ninth of the rights. A bit late as constitutions go (USA: first, Germany: fifth) but pretty consistent with many Europeans’ views on freedom of speech. In many European states free speech is not the same sort of fundamental right as it is in the US. Important, sure, but not quite as.

In defense of Germany: In the US rights come as amendments. The German constitution starts out with the human (and civil) rights at the very beginning. (Yes, someone wanted to distance themself from the Nazis.)

Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by ugh on Friday January 15, 2010 @06:10PM (#1056141)
It’s about the order of the fundamental rights, not so much where they are in the constitution.

Well, considering that the US bill of rights is freaking 158 years older than the German constitution, it wins always, anyway. Never mind the order :)

(Full disclaimer: I’m German and quite like our constitution. Just not so much when it comes to free speech. The article and how it’s been interpreted by the constitutional court is quite good, but I’m quite a fan of US style freedom of speech.)

Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by Zak on Friday January 15, 2010 @06:47PM (#1056187)
I've been told by Germans, none of whom were law enforcement or lawyers that calling someone an asshole or sticking up your middle finger is a finable offense. It's well known that publishing Nazi propaganda, denying the holocaust and the like are illegal. It seems to me that free speech is less than fundamental in Germany.

The US has a less than perfect record on the issue as well, with obscenity laws and the like.

Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by jrockway on Saturday January 16, 2010 @07:55AM (#1056862)
The US has a less than perfect record on the issue as well, with obscenity laws and the like.

To be fair, these laws have been consistently struck down by the Supreme Court.

That doesn't stop the government from continually passing similar laws and prosecuting people, however: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_of_America_v._Ext...

The real problem here is not with obscenity, though, but the concept of plea bargains. How many people will end up in prison because of unconstitutional laws before someone stands up against the oppressive regime?

Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by Zak on Saturday January 16, 2010 @01:38PM (#1057260)
To be fair, these laws have been consistently struck down by the Supreme Court.

I wish that were completely true. Unfortunately, it's not quite the case: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_test

Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by jrockway on Saturday January 16, 2010 @04:03PM (#1057480)
I agree that the Supreme Court got this completely wrong.
Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by eru on Monday January 18, 2010 @09:48AM (#1059961)
> I've been told by Germans, none of whom were law enforcement or lawyers that calling someone an asshole or sticking up your middle finger is a finable offense.

I can confirm this for offending a police officer or similar. But I haven't heard of a case where someone got fined for offending a `normal' private person. (I do not know whether the law covers this as well.)

Re:Italy wants citizens to officially apply to upload YouTub... by davidw on Friday January 15, 2010 @05:07PM (#1056007)