Re:How Finland plans to implement the first nation-wide basi...
by ams6110 on Friday November 13, 2015 @08:38AM
(#10559746)
It makes perfect sense. Each person has an income need, X. If they get B basic income, employer only needs to pay X - B whereas without basic income he needs to pay X.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How Finland plans to implement the first nation-wide basi...
by lhopki01 on Friday November 13, 2015 @09:29AM
(#10559989)
That's a poor implementation of basic income. If each person has a need X then B should be set at X. That way if they work for someone everything on top isn't for need but want. Gives them the ability to choose more.
Re:How Finland plans to implement the first nation-wide basi...
by njharman on Friday November 13, 2015 @12:17PM
(#10560953)
If B < X then B is not a basic income. It's like you said, an salary subsidy.
If B >= X then employees can walk away from any job for any reason. It inverts the labor market. Instead of employees competing for jobs, employers compete for labor. Portions of tech industry exhibit this inversion. Saleries, benefits, working conditions are off the charts compared to say Walmart line workers or Amazon pickers.
Re:How Finland plans to implement the first nation-wide basi...
by saiya-jin on Friday November 13, 2015 @09:39AM
(#10560034)
Agreed, look at it this way - most people don't earn minimum, but more. They will still work to keep their standards (paying rents, mortgages, cars, kids, lifestyle they are used to etc.). Employers are not dumb, they will reflect this immediately.
A healthy society should always motivate people to WORK and produce products/services, that's what keeps society running. If main goal of BI is to remove that motivation, I fail to see it as a step in right direction.