Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012)
by kazinator on Thursday November 12, 2015 @09:37PM
(#10557698)
That's how the site works. If thousands of users think nothing of your comment, but two downvote it, there you go: two downvotes.
On HN, bland comments which attract no upvotes have to be spotlessly inoffensive to every imaginable mindset so that they survive the 24 hour "statute of limitations" for downvotes.
... keeping in mind that some people punish blandness itself with a downvote!
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012)
by cpncrunch on Thursday November 12, 2015 @11:54PM
(#10558085)
Yes, that makes sense (and thanks for your other, longer explanation, kazinator). I still feel that downvotes should have an explanation attached, as there is some negativity expressed in downvoting, but I realise that probably isn't going to happen.
I'm guessing the shortness of your comment and the negativity without sources made a difference? But that's just a guess.