If that is true, the author should avoid words like "secure" and "unbreakable".
Is RC4 secure? For this use-case, yes.
That was the point where I went to go write an HN comment, before seeing that Sean had already written it.
Is RC4 secure? No.
I initially thought the article was satire.
> but the goal isn't to make a strong or useful encryption tool
> > With this (and your computer) you can secure a message with a password in a way that's unbreakable. I can't break it, your government can't break it, other people's governments can't break it. Secure.
Some governments execute their citizens. If a crypto tool is neither strong nor useful it probably shouldn't be described as such.
It's like building an electric motor out of some scrap wire and some fridge magnets - the motor isn't really useful for anything, but it teaches the basic idea in a way that anybody can appreciate. A useful motor would have bearings, a commutator, multiple windings, an iron core, etc., but adding all that stuff just obscures the basics. Criticizing a school-kid's motor for being weak and inefficient is completely missing the point.
This program isn't supposed to be useful. It's supposed to prove a point.