News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by mrmcd on Thursday November 12, 2015 @01:32PM (#10555116)
One thing I read that isn't often mentioned is how liquidation preference for late rounds can drive a lot of these insane valuations.

For example, let's say you raise $250MM in a series E at a 10B post money. As a company/founder, this makes you look awesome on paper and super valuable as a company. Meanwhile, the series E investors usually have the top priority for liquidation, meaning the risk is actually pretty small, since the sale/IPO value would have to go below 250MM before you lose money.

The real people getting screwed by these paper unicorns though are the late stage employees being sold options as compensation.

Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by aptimpropriety on Thursday November 12, 2015 @02:00PM (#10555322)
But Fidelity isn't writing down the value of the company, it's writing down the value of its shares. Do you have any guesses as to what this means, given they are probably the most senior equityholders on this investment?

My suspicion (from experience in the mutual fund industry) is that this is tax accounting related. Overly simplistic explanation: Mutual funds typically distribute short term capital gains at year-end, which is taxed as ordinary income (~40%), not capital gains (~15%).

Managers of funds that hold private securities actually have the choice to 'mark down' the prices of their securities in any given month. Think of it like valuing a house - if you want to value your total net worth, you can mark your price as what you want, to an extent (see Trump). Managers often use this flexibility to 'bury' losses in down times, or for tax advantages.

Finally, can't agree enough about who loses in these cases. Employees who vastly over-value options are the folks who lose in this case. Investments made by institutional folks like Fidelity are too small to even register as a blip to their overall funds, and those funds are diversified and managed to handle downturns in sectors like this.

Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by the_watcher on Thursday November 12, 2015 @02:08PM (#10555383)
The tax implications are interesting, haven't heard it brought up before.
Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by maxerickson on Thursday November 12, 2015 @02:16PM (#10555421)
These funds have 10s of billions of dollars of investments, a few tens of millions here or there does not have significant tax implications.

Here's one of the Fidelity funds invested in Snapchat:

https://fundresearch.fidelity.com/mutual-funds/composition/3...

It's got $40 billion under management.

There's a document findable from there that lists their Snapchat investment as $10 million (Prospectus and Reports->Monthly Holdings report).

The number 1 holding of that fund is $2,192,901,654 of Apple. So they get roughly $10 million each time Apple pays a quarterly dividend.

Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by Stasis5001 on Thursday November 12, 2015 @02:53PM (#10555640)
That's not exactly fair. They hold many assets, so of course any action on any individual asset may not have a significant effect. However, if they behave similarly across all similar assets, it will have an effect on the overall fund.
Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by maxerickson on Thursday November 12, 2015 @03:02PM (#10555694)
I think the percent of holdings argument is going to apply to these funds at Fidelity even if you take all the startups they own together. I guess "tens of millions" becomes excessively dismissive though.
Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by Stasis5001 on Thursday November 12, 2015 @03:21PM (#10555822)
Sure but even still, suppose an analyst saves all of Fidelity's clients 1M in two days worth of work. We can't dismiss that as silly because that savings is so small compared to 5 trillion AUM, right?
Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by maxerickson on Thursday November 12, 2015 @03:27PM (#10555866)
I think it wouldn't be Hacker News.

I'd also like someone who understands the issue well to let us know whether these mark downs have any tax implications to begin with. I think it might sometimes be the case that marking down such a holding would allow recognition of a tax loss but I don't think that is going on here.

Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by aptimpropriety on Thursday November 12, 2015 @03:55PM (#10556040)
Stasis' logic is along the right lines - you need to think about it in terms of portfolio management strategy. Effectively, the manager is trying to switch as much of the gains of their fund from being taxed at 40% to being taxed at 15%. A decent explanation here: http://www.nicholasfunds.com/dividend_info.html

You're right that it won't be a large drop in the bucket. It's not news because it's a large drop in a bucket, it's news because its a valuation change on companies many here follow. Nonetheless, one could object to poor management if Fidelity didn't take this action, regardless of size.

Note - this only gets at the 'why now' part of the motivation. What it means for 1) their internal company valuations and 2) implications for shareholders without liquidation preferences is more interesting.

Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by maxerickson on Thursday November 12, 2015 @04:00PM (#10556075)
Can you explain the mechanism where it is a tax loss and show where Fidelity has used it? That sounds like a gotcha, but I'm genuinely curious if it is clearly the case that they can recognize a tax loss here.

I think the mark down mostly does two things. It allows Fidelity to honestly inform their customers what they hold, and it signals to the startups that things aren't necessarily going the way Fidelity would like to see them go.

Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by aptimpropriety on Thursday November 12, 2015 @03:59PM (#10556070)
Another good explanation: http://www.cnbc.com/2014/11/26/beware-of-the-year-end-mutual...

If these securities have been held for <1 year, their gain/loss goes into the short term bucket. So losses (in this case, writedowns) can offset the size of distribution, which is a bad deal for investors.

To a personal investor (e.g. mentioned in the world of WealthFront/Betterment), this is 'tax loss harvesting'.

Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by maxerickson on Thursday November 12, 2015 @04:01PM (#10556085)
Yes, I understand what capital gains and losses are. Is there one actually involved here?
Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by mrgordon on Thursday November 12, 2015 @06:26PM (#10556935)
Yeah agreed. The linked article mentions distributing income but snapchat has no dividends so it seems irrelevant. I'm not clear how this has any effect on Fidelity's taxes for 2015. It seems like its just bringing the valuations closer to what Fidelity expects they are worth so there are no surprises later.
Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by dubroff on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:09PM (#10556495)
What do you mean by this "The real people getting screwed by these paper unicorns though are the late stage employees being sold options as compensation"?

I'm currently a student job searching and this seems pretty relevant.

Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by balls187 on Thursday November 12, 2015 @06:08PM (#10556851)
Employees and Investors of private companies hold different class(es) of stock.

Employees (and Founders) have common stock, while Investors get preferred stock.

Preferred stock carries with it a "liquidation preference", which basically means holders of that stock get paid out first during a liquidity event, including some multiple of their original investment. What ever is left, is divided among the holders of common stock.

If the company is publicly traded, then all owners of stock hold the same class of stock (common).

Re:Fidelity Devalues Stake in Blue Bottle, Dataminr, Zenefit... by aidenn0 on Thursday November 12, 2015 @06:21PM (#10556911)
You get options offered at a strike price that (for tax reasons) usually matches the market value of the company. If the company is way overvalued on paper, that makes the options essentially worthless, as the strike price is higher than what you could trade the shares for.