My hunch is founders will find a way to block such sales not only to avoid the surprises in new valuations but also the headache of managing that.
Given the different share rights of preferred and common stock in a pre-IPO company, selling common shares does not look anything at all like an "investment round" in the typical sense. It does however impact the 409a valuation and could cause new employees to get a higher strike price on their options when they join.
The other interesting thing is the FB/SecondMarket situation did actually look like an investment round in the way that it set a share price and valuation. From what I remember SecondMarket set up weekly auctions for FB shares right up until the IPO and guess what the IPO did? Closed at the open.
There is no way to tell but I bet if the SecondMarket sales hadn't happened it would have done what most hot tech IPOs do, set an artificially low IPO price and cash in on the pop.
Regardless of the merits of the restriction, I can see why it would similarly be applied here.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't the motivation for that to keep unsophisticated investors out, and limit it people with money to lose? I think there are similar restrictions on hedge funds, too.
I can see the logic behind that, since it's much more likely for a startup to go bust, and I wouldn't want to see regular people losing their life savings. Though, personally, I think I'd prefer there just be a limit based on something like percentage of net worth invested in these sorts of things.
Plus, I don't think founders will really like this as it will probably find a different valuation than they thought they had, see snapchat.