First; to make the broad generalization that "everyone lived in small self-contained communities" is frankly laughable, assuming the statement isn't taken out of a context that constrains the "everyone" in that quote. Yes, we didn't have the megacities we have today, but you certainly couldn't say "everyone would know who was dating the baker's daughter" somewhere like Pompei or Tikal.
Secondly, even if you want to argue the cities case, national/international trade has existed almost as long as established civilization. It would have been VERY easy to move among trade lanes and find a new home, if your "anonymity" had been compromised in a way you didn't like in one place. Starting with a truly clean slate in the modern age is FAR more difficult; I'd argue that we've been slowly shrinking the degree of anonymity one can re-achieve. (there is good historical precedent for movement via trade if you look at, to pull one example off the top of my head, certain trade-oriented tribes in central-south native american culture. They would regularly spread out to other small groups in which their past was as anonymous as could possibly get; there is good record of american settlers traveling with them to embed themselves in the admittedly small tribal cultures, but the size alone does not moot ones ability to seek anonymity.)
Specifically he feels that the way Vint Cerf argued may have been applicable to his culture but many others less so.
His point was that privacy was present in many of these cultures before the advent of cities and that cities did not simply invent privacy out of thin air.
That said I think a lot of this is misconstruing on both sides.
My personal opinion is privacy and an expectation of it existed well before cities or even towns and that what really come with cities was anonymity. Which is a different concept entirely.
I think it would be fair to say if you sent a rider or a pigeon so a trusted advisor you had an expectation others would not hear/read your message, this is true of the postal system and one would expect of telephone and Internet communications.
However, things get really rough when cities happened. Because of the rise of anonymity law enforcement needed new powers to actually find perpetrators of crimes. As such some privacy was sacrificed in the name of making our communities safer. Mostly in the form of allowing law enforcement some limited wire tap and post interception powers.
Unfortunately this didn't map very well to the Internet because of the nature of the 2 mediums. Intercepting someones written and spoken communications between another human is one thing. Being able to spy on what is effectively their thoughts and interests is entirely another. The bandwidth and expression of the Internet and the rich mediums we have built on it are greatly underestimated by the frankly out of date politicians and policy makers of today. They don't realise how much damage they are potentially doing to the future of such a promising system.
When did "cities happen"? Rome had more than a million residents about 2,000 years ago. Cities like Athens and Alexandria had over 100,000 residents centuries before that. I think I understand the point you're making, that anonymity within a community is easier to achieve when the community is large, but that's not the only anonymity available.
Before cities, we already had anonymity due to fleeting associations (e.g. nomadic groups, traveling merchants), due to separated communities (e.g. soldiers did not know each others' past, their homes would not have known their actions), or due to migration (e.g. leaving one community and joining another).
Those forms of anonymity have mostly disappeared, not because "cities happened", but because of better administration. So far, our administrative capability has always been limited by the amount of effort it required. What has changed with the Internet is that we now leave a (digital) papertrail of almost everything we do, so there is no longer an effort-based limit on the amount of records we can preserve.
That to me is what makes Cerf's comment unpalatable (I hadn't encountered it before): to pretend that "we've never had anonymity" is foolish at best, and manipulative at worst. Given his current employer, I'm more inclined towards the latter.
Another poster already commented that "what we now call privacy, used to be called freedom and liberty". I think that's a very good one-liner, but it's not really accurate: privacy is a requisite for freedom and liberty, but it's not the same thing. This is probably the first time (since the StaSi) that that requisite has come under so much attack, which is probably why it's receiving so much more attention than before.
I also think like Vint Cerf, that privacy is an artifact of modern society. I also think that since modern society is the one we find ourselves in, that privacy should be aggressively protected. Privacy is more important now than ever precisely because we're an urbanized and connected society.
I have never had a problem with an investigator hanging out somewhere writing down license plate numbers. But take issue with always-on automated license plate readers scanning where everyone is all the time. It's a difference in resources.
And to go full Godwin, the Nazis were far more effective with IBM's help.
That's an interesting and important point I learned to appreciate in an explicit form only recently. Thank you for making it.
That said, I still don't see from a practical point, how we can expect to keep privacy and progress? The always-on automated license plate readers exist because cameras and computing power are dirt chip now, and no amount of effort sans starting a third world war and rolling us back to medieval times will revert that. Laws are weaker than technology, and the current development will make it only easier to create more complex and cheaper machines that replicate various functions of humans, only faster and better.
We could try and fight for changes in law that would make mass-scale data collection illegal, but that would not make it impossible or unfeasible - it will only limit the access to "the good guys". So criminals, creeps and government services (at least those secret ones) will keep spying on us anyway, while we would be throwing away a lot of potential improvements and scientific advancements that could be enabled by a "god's eye" view.
And so I sometimes wonder, since we can't put the genie back in the box, and fighting it only means giving up our own powers while merely inconveniencing the bad guys, maybe we should just embrace the society that's becoming self-aware and make sure this awareness is put to a good use?
ETA:
> And to go full Godwin, the Nazis were far more effective with IBM's help.
True, but I don't think we should frame it as anything else as (1930/1940) IBM helping evil people who they know were evil. The Nazis were equally more effective with help of any other country that provided them with materials they used for war.
On the other hand, we are all better off thanks to IBM, so this can't be an argument against general-purpose computing, or punchcards and identification numbers.
I don't follow. How are the two mutually exclusive? Your false dichotomy between license plate readers and medieval times isn't very convincing to me.
> Laws are weaker than technology
Really? So since it is technologically possible for me to remove my license plates from my car, no judge will be able to make me put them back?
And, since it is technologically possible, it is ok for others to clean out your bank account, and you would have no redress other than to hack your money back to you?
What is the current direction of technological progress? More computing. Faster computing. More ubiquitous computing. More connectivity. Leveraging all that for optimization. Today we have cameras so small that every one is carrying two of them in their pocket. Tomorrow, at least one of which will be replaced or augmented with a geometry scanner. Scientists want to have nanosats in orbit that will keep continuous, real-time surveillance of the planet. Can't you really see that almost everything we do now erodes privacy?
Or in more theoretical sense - every single thing you do generates ripples in reality that spread and interact with other things (generating more ripples) with the speed of light. Every thing you say or do leaves traces. Most of them escape our notice, because there's only so much things we can pay attention to. But they are still there, and with more sensors and more computing powers, we're untangling the great web of causality. Whatever is not known we can try to infer. Privacy disappears with the amount of compute we can throw at it.
> Really? So since it is technologically possible for me to remove my license plates from my car, no judge will be able to make me put them back?
You know that your car probably has several RFID tags and radio chips in various places like e.g. tires? With time it may be the case that no judge will care to make you put them back - they won't need to.
Anyway, my point does not apply to individuals, but on a large scale. Whenever a new technology arrives that is so useful/popular that lots of people start to use it, laws and customs adjust to accomodate it. Since laws and customs follow technological progress and not the other way around, it follows that laws are weaker than technology.