News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by bumbledraven on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:16PM (#10550096)
patio11 wrote on Twitter (https://www.twitter.com/patio11/status/664551822120476672):

> Tor is having a fit of institutional pique that researchers are compromising the network's privacy guarantees by, well, looking at it.

> If you write security software, and you're not praying that loyal opposition hits you with everything they've got, you're not doing security

> Tor is intended to be, and is marketed as, robust against nation state adversaries. It cannot possibly be so if it worries about academics.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by Hello71 on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:40PM (#10550229)
I believe the complaint here is not that they were analyzing the software, but that they were launching active attacks and using the results in an unethical manner, i.e. to conduct possibly-illegal criminal investigations. This is Not OK in the same way that it's Not OK to go around breaking into people's houses with lockpicks and searching them on the grounds that you are conducting lock research. Note that I understand that physical lock security is a relatively well-settled field. That is not relevant to the point at hand; even if it were an important thing to study, it would be Not OK for the government to be paying people to go around picking locks.

Edit: Furthermore, by the same logic, it is acceptable for the government to do nearly anything illegal in order to conduct "research". Microsoft, Google, and co claim to be secure, so therefore it should be OK for the government to be attacking them.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by comex on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:38PM (#10550215)
A group that performs an actual attack, hands the result to a nation state adversary, and doesn't publish the results either before or after (except in the abstract of a withdrawn talk) is hardly the "loyal opposition".

edit: Academics are not Obama's proverbial JV team. One should expect them to be as smart as those working for internal agencies, if somewhat less focused on attacking real-world systems. It seems that in this case, the only difference is that they're somewhat worse at keeping secrets, but given that the talk was withdrawn, it's not that they didn't try. So I don't see the grounds for the implicit suggestion in the quoted tweets that they aren't 'real' adversaries.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by cuckcuckspruce on Thursday November 12, 2015 @09:52AM (#10553424)
> One should expect them to be as smart as those working for internal agencies, if somewhat less focused on attacking real-world systems.

It's this reason, along with DARPA and similar funding, that I call it the military-industrial-(higher-)education complex.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by kevinchen on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:39PM (#10550219)
This misses the point entirely. Nobody is saying that security researchers shouldn't find vulnerabilities.

The problem is that rather than publishing or filing a bug, the researchers helped the government exploit it for $1M. Effectively the same as selling the exploit on the black market.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by XorNot on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:28PM (#10551121)
Yeaaaahhhh no.

In exactly the same way that the military is not mercenaries.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by hobs on Thursday November 12, 2015 @12:54AM (#10551535)
And civilians are not the military.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by bri3d on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:47PM (#10550275)
If, as the Tor blog post insinuates, the product of the CMU research was "targeted data dump to the Feds to investigate criminal activity," I could see the hand-wringing being warranted. That's paying a university to do law enforcement work.

If the product was (as it seems based on public information) "paper about how to attack Tor along with a couple of case studies," I really don't see the problem.

The kerfuffle around the talk and paper's release is certainly interesting in its own right, though.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by gwright on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:15PM (#10551076)
> That's paying a university to do law enforcement work.

Not really. The organization involved is SEI, a Federally Funded Research and Development Center sponsored by the Department of Defense. Not at all the same thing as CMU.

Mentioning this for clarity, not as a statement about the actually activities.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by zurn on Thursday November 12, 2015 @03:09AM (#10551908)
So it's FBI paying the military to do law enforcement work. Not really better.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by abdullahkhalids on Thursday November 12, 2015 @12:21AM (#10551441)
A lot of people in this thread are misreading the blogpost. The primary complaint is against Feds and not CMU[1], specifically that the Feds used a loophole in the legal system to exploit Tor. They are then asking the university and researchers to be more careful about the funding/nature of their research and blaming them for bringing academic security research into dispute.

I agree that some of the middle paragraphs could have been worded more carefully.

[1] "Civil liberties are under attack if law enforcement believes it can circumvent the rules of evidence by outsourcing police work to universities." from post

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by ikeboy on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:19PM (#10550113)
There's a difference between white hat and black hat. Working for the other side is not white hat, and arguably security software writers should only welcome white hat research.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by tedunangst on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:40PM (#10550227)
Everything would be so much simpler if the people writing "secure" software could pick who got to attack it.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by unethical_ban on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @07:52PM (#10550558)
It's stunning that you may have read this conversation and still think people have an issue with security research on Tor in general.

The testing, and perhaps even the specific methods of the this test, are not the question. The question is the morality of CMU being paid by authorities to uncover PII about hidden services and report back to them.

Test the system (potentially with your own uni's red/blue teams instead of on other 'public' hidden services) and report back anonymized reports of the data. One can say "Doing X, I got result Y" without giving out the personal details of results, much less to the FBI.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by caf on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @08:08PM (#10550627)
Yes. It's the difference between pubishing a paper "How to break TLS" and a paper "How to break TLS, with an appendix of 10,000 credit card numbers I logged using this method".
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by eadz on Thursday November 12, 2015 @11:36AM (#10554184)
this.

Doing the legwork of law enforcement, is different from doing research.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by tptacek on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @09:16PM (#10550875)
It's not stunning. It is a long-running controversy with Tor and its operators. Most of what's in the "Ethical Tor Research Guidelines" is common-sense, but some of it potentially forecloses important research.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by tedunangst on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @08:37PM (#10550742)
The comment I replied to said developers should only welcome white hat attackers. We seem vaguely agreed that black hats won't stop attacking because they are unwelcome, so what change is effected by only welcoming white hats?
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by Canada on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:18PM (#10551093)
To use the lock analogy:

It's not OK to break into random houses under the guise of lock picking research. Even if it is research, it's still B&E.

However, the designer/manufacturer/seller/marketer of the defeated locks would look silly to come out and say, "No fair, you're not allowed to pick those locks. We clearly said you could only do that in our test lab!"

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by mmcwilliams on Thursday November 12, 2015 @11:58AM (#10554346)
What if those locks were willingly sent from house to house with the intention that the sending would obscure their source/destination? If you signed your house up to be one of those locations and decided to try to pick some of the locks that were shipped through your house, you would consider that B&E?
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by tedunangst on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:22PM (#10551288)
So where does that leave the guy who discovered nearly all hotel locks are trivially hackable?
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by jacquesm on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:24AM (#10552284)
I don't recall Cody going into a number of rooms, photographing their contents and sharing those photographs with the authorities.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by maxerickson on Thursday November 12, 2015 @07:24AM (#10552688)
If I understand correctly, he did a lot of the work with the idea of selling hotels an alternative to the keycard programmers that come with the locks, and the company that did that purchased stuff to work with.

This story has lots of discussion of it:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4281722

Especially this comment:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4282666

(Also, not all hotels, just lots and lots of them that used that particular implementation)

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by Canada on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:47PM (#10551360)
I'm pretty sure everyone here would mock the hotel lock vendors for complaining... even if a government paid that guy to illegally break into a bunch of hotel rooms.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by nitrogen on Thursday November 12, 2015 @12:14AM (#10551428)
No, if your scenario occurred, there would be a similar sentiment as in the thread here. Motive matters.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by pyre on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:48PM (#10550284)
Your position seems to imply that "bank robbery" should not be a crime because banks are supposed to be secure, and it's their own fault that there was a flaw in the system. I think that reasonable people can conclude that a system should be secure, there are things that "shouldn't" be done, regardless of the security of the system. It's not to say that "outlaws" won't break the law, but that we view their actions as negative (even if in a perfect world their actions would be futile).
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by URSpider94 on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:23PM (#10551292)
First of all, just as copying someone's source code isn't the same as stealing their laptop, there is a well-established principle that hacking someone's network isn't the same as breaking into their physical premises.

Second, they may have broken into the proverbial bank, but they didn't steal anything while they were there. At most, they photocopied the list of who is renting safe deposit boxes at that branch. Hardly grand theft.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by pyre on Thursday November 12, 2015 @10:30AM (#10553700)
You take the analogy too literal. The idea is that the actions of the attacker can be agreed to be negative, even if security is lax on the victim's side. You don't say "Welp, they were asking for it!" and call it a day.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by tedunangst on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:54PM (#10550312)
I would not keep my valuables in a bank whose security consisted of a "keep out" sign.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by pyre on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:58PM (#10550330)
I didn't imply that you should. My statement still stands. While "they shouldn't have done X" is not security, that doesn't mean that the statement is devoid of meaning, or that we should ignore the question of whether or not "they should have done X."

Edit: Your statements seem to imply that because "100% security" would mean that anyone "doing X" would have no result, then everyone should be allowed to "do X" without question.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by tedunangst on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @07:10PM (#10550381)
I am saying that regardless of what we'd like to expect, we should prepare for the unexpected. Picking your attacker is doomed to fail; don't try. I don't think this is controversial.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by detaro on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @08:07PM (#10550620)
It isn't. I also fail to see what it has to do with the discussion at hand. The issue IMHO is not that CMU did research on Tor, or that the US government paid for research into the security of Tor, but the question if the FBI basically outsourced investigations to researchers, and if yes, on what legal basis this happened.

Yes, that they succeeded to collect information is a failure of Tor and makes it less trustworthy, I don't think that's contested by anyone here.

Attacking real users in the process of finding security bugs and how to deal with captured data is the (separate) ethical issue here.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by SOLAR_FIELDS on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @07:38PM (#10550498)
I would not be supportive of a government that pays people to attempt to rob my bank without telling me or my bank in the name of "security research", even if their intention was never to steal money. Regardless of what was posted on the door.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by ikeboy on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:42PM (#10550241)
But after-the-fact reputational effects seem fine, if the action was unethical.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by striking on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:21PM (#10550125)
Yeah, but CMU allegedly got paid a pretty big chunk of money for it. If they were just doing research, whatever. But $1m? That's a whole lot of taxpayer money.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by tedunangst on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:56PM (#10550324)
$1M is not a lot of money. That's not nation state money; that's Tim Tebow money.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by brazzledazzle on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @07:48PM (#10550543)
That's irrelevant to his point.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by twblalock on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @08:07PM (#10550623)
Not entirely. A lot of universities get taxpayer money to do research, and $1m is not out of the normal range for research funding in science and technology.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by doktrin on Thursday November 12, 2015 @03:03AM (#10551882)
In this context, $1mm is chump change.
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by jeromegv on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:25PM (#10550147)
Well TOR is also funded by taxpayer money...
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by striking on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:39PM (#10550223)
My point was "this is more money than CMU should have gotten for looking into the Tor network, especially from the FBI" rather than "taxpayers paid for this"
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by structural on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:58PM (#10551217)
In the government contracting world, $1m is an absolutely tiny program - keep in mind that this covers not only the research, but also all the overhead / facilities / computers / keeping the lights on stuff.

$1m will cover something like 3-4 staff for about a year. Less, if they're senior people.

Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by federico3 on Thursday November 12, 2015 @10:24AM (#10553659)
*Tor
Re:Did the FBI Pay a University to Attack Tor Users? by borkabrak on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:24PM (#10550138)
Your points are well-taken, but I would expect academics to be the only demographic more likely than governments to compromise a well-designed security system.

Although I suppose the academics I mean aren't undergrads..