Edit: Furthermore, by the same logic, it is acceptable for the government to do nearly anything illegal in order to conduct "research". Microsoft, Google, and co claim to be secure, so therefore it should be OK for the government to be attacking them.
edit: Academics are not Obama's proverbial JV team. One should expect them to be as smart as those working for internal agencies, if somewhat less focused on attacking real-world systems. It seems that in this case, the only difference is that they're somewhat worse at keeping secrets, but given that the talk was withdrawn, it's not that they didn't try. So I don't see the grounds for the implicit suggestion in the quoted tweets that they aren't 'real' adversaries.
It's this reason, along with DARPA and similar funding, that I call it the military-industrial-(higher-)education complex.
The problem is that rather than publishing or filing a bug, the researchers helped the government exploit it for $1M. Effectively the same as selling the exploit on the black market.
In exactly the same way that the military is not mercenaries.
If the product was (as it seems based on public information) "paper about how to attack Tor along with a couple of case studies," I really don't see the problem.
The kerfuffle around the talk and paper's release is certainly interesting in its own right, though.
Not really. The organization involved is SEI, a Federally Funded Research and Development Center sponsored by the Department of Defense. Not at all the same thing as CMU.
Mentioning this for clarity, not as a statement about the actually activities.
I agree that some of the middle paragraphs could have been worded more carefully.
[1] "Civil liberties are under attack if law enforcement believes it can circumvent the rules of evidence by outsourcing police work to universities." from post
The testing, and perhaps even the specific methods of the this test, are not the question. The question is the morality of CMU being paid by authorities to uncover PII about hidden services and report back to them.
Test the system (potentially with your own uni's red/blue teams instead of on other 'public' hidden services) and report back anonymized reports of the data. One can say "Doing X, I got result Y" without giving out the personal details of results, much less to the FBI.
Doing the legwork of law enforcement, is different from doing research.
It's not OK to break into random houses under the guise of lock picking research. Even if it is research, it's still B&E.
However, the designer/manufacturer/seller/marketer of the defeated locks would look silly to come out and say, "No fair, you're not allowed to pick those locks. We clearly said you could only do that in our test lab!"
This story has lots of discussion of it:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4281722
Especially this comment:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4282666
(Also, not all hotels, just lots and lots of them that used that particular implementation)
Second, they may have broken into the proverbial bank, but they didn't steal anything while they were there. At most, they photocopied the list of who is renting safe deposit boxes at that branch. Hardly grand theft.
Edit: Your statements seem to imply that because "100% security" would mean that anyone "doing X" would have no result, then everyone should be allowed to "do X" without question.
Yes, that they succeeded to collect information is a failure of Tor and makes it less trustworthy, I don't think that's contested by anyone here.
Attacking real users in the process of finding security bugs and how to deal with captured data is the (separate) ethical issue here.
$1m will cover something like 3-4 staff for about a year. Less, if they're senior people.
Although I suppose the academics I mean aren't undergrads..
> Tor is having a fit of institutional pique that researchers are compromising the network's privacy guarantees by, well, looking at it.
> If you write security software, and you're not praying that loyal opposition hits you with everything they've got, you're not doing security
> Tor is intended to be, and is marketed as, robust against nation state adversaries. It cannot possibly be so if it worries about academics.